Making sense of all what?

As we close out the first full week of 2021, I find it hard to make any sense of what has happened in our country.

The week began on a hopeful note that Jon Ossoff and Reverend Raphael Warnock would be successful and they were. But then we experienced one of the darkest days in America’s recent history. I don’t need to recount for you the facts (particularly since we are learning more and more) or name the traitorous individuals who wrought such horrifying chaos and violence in a coup attempt fomented by Trump. But I do want to express what has been roiling up in my head and heart.

First, we have to get through the next eleven days and make it to the inauguration (Yay Joe and Kamala). After that, we need a national reckoning to determine how we got here and how to fix it. While I certainly don’t know how we are going to fix this, I do think history can provide some of an explanation as to how we got here.

From what I can see, we got to January 6, 2021 through a history of extreme racial inequity and the man who paraded through the Capitol with the Confederate battle flag encapsulated, in that one moment, what I am talking about.[1] The dichotomy between the police response to what happened on the 6th and what happened all over the country during the BLM protests is no coincidence. 

Can we connect the dots from the Revolution to the Civil War to today? Yes.

As we all learned in elementary school, when this nation was founded slavery was (for too many) an accepted “fact” of life. What you might not have been taught in elementary school is that many of the southern colonies advocated for revolution in part to perpetuate slavery, fearing Great Britain would abolish it.[2] While some of the founding fathers voiced objections to slavery and they tellingly avoided using that word in the document, they enacted numerous provisions in the Constitution to protect it (more than just the three-fifths clause).[3]

Since I grew up and went to college in the Northeast, it wasn’t until I moved to the Midwest that I discovered there are people who believe the Civil War was fought for “states’ rights.” If by that they mean the “right” to own slaves, I guess that’s true. Let’s put a lie to this argument here and now with the words of Alexander Stephens, the vice president of the Confederacy from his “Cornerstone” speech of 1861:

 Our new government is founded upon exactly the opposite idea [of equality of the races]; its foundations are laid, its cornerstone rests, upon the great truth that the negro is not equal to the white man; that slavery subordination to the superior race is his natural and normal condition. This, our new Government, is the first, in the history of the world, based upon this great physical, philosophical, and moral truth.[4]

So where did all this “state’ rights” bullshit come from?

 Have you heard of “The Lost Cause”? It is one of America’s most successful disinformation campaigns. While the Civil War devastated Southern cities, it also shattered the Southern psyche. Believing that they had the superior society, Southerners searched for a substitute for military victory and created an image of the war as a “great heroic epic” to save the true (i.e. White) America.[5] The most notable propaganda used to rewrite the Civil War was the “states’ rights” argument plus the roughly 700 Confederate monuments across more than thirty-one states and the District of Columbia erected well after the war ended.[6]

 On Wednesday, Senator Ted Cruz advocated for a “compromise” similar to that which settled the disputed 1876 presidential election. Ironically (or not), this compromise lead to a much-too-early end of Reconstruction and the beginning of the Jim Crow era. 

 Fast-forward to Brown v. The Board of Education.[7]

 We know that the Brown ruling ordered an end to segregated schools, but it was also a catalyst for no less than a “fifth-column assault on American democratic governance.”[8]

 Really Cele? Come on. Be serious.

 Oh, I am serious. While I can’t articulate it as well as Nancy McLean has (see footnote 8 and read that book), here it is in a nutshell: Brown showed that the federal government would no longer defer to “states’ rights” and would enforce democratic standards of fair treatment and equal protection under the law. This gave rise to what is euphemistically called “Libertarianism,” but meaning at its core unrestrained capitalism and the takeover of public institutions by corporations with the goal of radically reducing the freedom of the many.[9] Their success in this endeavor has resulted in, among other things, the crippling of trade unions, deregulation of corporations, shifting of taxes to the less well-off, and voting restrictions. “Libertarians” will say “I just want us all to be free – you don’t control me and I don’t control you.” But by “you” they mean the majority of Americans and what they really want is a return to oligarchy, specifically, White oligarchy.[10]

 Then there was the “Southern Strategy” of Nixon and his ilk.

Then there was Ronald Reagan’s vilification of “welfare queens.”

 Then there was George H. W. Bush’s Willie Horton campaign.

 In furtherance of White oligarchy, Republicans have waged a wholesale P.R. campaign to associate public goods and services with “undeserving” communities of color.[11] When they argue for privatization it is fundamentally a code-word for segregation. 

 Now to the rise of Donald Trump. Sure, he had been on T.V. and was made to look like a successful businessman, but his political ascent started with “birtherism,” the lie that Barack Obama was not born in Hawai’i. Did he pursue this because he didn’t like Obama? Who knows?  What we do know is that he knew that this false claim would resonate with a large number of White Americans. He continued down that path when he came down the escalator in 2015 pushing another lie that “Mexicans” were to blame for America’s troubles. Lie after lie after lie, during these past four years, Trump has fed the irrational fear of the far-right and White supremacists’ of losing status, wealth, and political power.[12] By targeting the Black communities of Detroit, Philadelphia, Atlanta, and Milwaukee with false voter fraud claims, Trump and the Kraken team exposed their goal of suppressing Black voters.[13]

 Now that the Trump administration is ending, we will not heal by just turning the page. Our problems are greater and more long-standing than Trump: White supremacy is a deep iceberg that has been intentionally grown over time. The extreme violence unleashed this week is just the tip of that iceberg and it is high time we stop it from hiding under the surface.[14]

 The only way we have been able to combat racism in this country has been through strong federal intervention which is one reason why the right has continually tried to weaken the federal government. Given the recent court-packing, will we be able to find accountability and justice? 

 Only if we demand it. 

 Do not forget. Do not forgive. 

 These are the right words: Treason. Sedition. Fascism. 

 If they are not held accountable, they will do it again. Chavez and Hitler didn’t succeed the first time.

 “Those who were part of the problem are not part of the solution.”[15]

 Laugh at (or better yet, ignore) the WSJ editorial page, Fox News, Newsmax, OANN and the rest. Give them no quarter. 

 Fight voter suppression. The organization Let America Vote can help you get informed and take action. Go to https://letamericavote.wpengine.com

 Learn (along with me) how to be an antiracist.[16]

 Keep the faith.[17]


_______________________________________

[1] The painting he is strutting past is that of Republican Senator Charles Sumner, the Massachusetts abolitionist who was severely beaten by pro-slavery Representative Preston Brooks on 22 May 1856. Wikipedia.org, “Caning of Charles Sumner,” 08:28, 7 January 2021; Clint Smith, “The Whole Story in a Single Photo,” The Atlantic, 8 January 2021.

[2] Simon Schama, “Dirty Little Secret,” Smithsonian Magazine (May 2006) (https://www.smithsonianmag.com/history/dirty-little-secret-115579444/).

[3] Steven Mintz, “Historical Context: The Constitution and Slavery,” History Resources (no date) (https://www.gilderlehrman.org/history-resources/teaching-resource/historical-context-constitution-and-slavery).

[4] “Modern History Sourcebook: Alexander H. Stephens (1812-1883): Cornerstone Address, March 21, 1861” Fordham University (https://sourcebooks.fordham.edu/mod/1861stephens.asp).

[5] Mitch Landrieu [Mayor of New Orleans], “How I Learned About the ‘Cult of the Lost Cause,’” Smithsonian Magazine, 12 March 2018 (https://www.smithsonianmag.com/history/how-i-learned-about-cult-lost-cause-180968426/).

[6] Far exceeding the eleven states that seceded. Becky Little, “How the US Got So Many Confederate Monuments,” 12 June 2020, History.com (https://www.history.com/news/how-the-u-s-got-so-many-confederate-monuments).

[7] Not to ignore that era, but others have written so much more eloquently than I ever could.

[8] Nancy McLean, Democracy in Chains: The Deep History of the Radical Right’s Stealth Plan for America (New York: Penguin Books, 2017), xxxii.

[9] Ibid., xxx.

[10] See also, Jane Mayer, Dark Money: The Hidden History of the Billionaires Behind the Rise of the Radical Right (New York: Doubleday, 2016); Stuart Stevens, It Was All a Lie: How the Republican Party Became Donald Trump (New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 2020); Jacob S. Hacker and Paul Pierson, Let them Eat Tweets: How the Right Rules in and Age of Extreme Inequality (New York: Liveright Publishing Corp., 2020).

[11] Brittaney Cooper, “Segregationists never went away: We just call them ‘small government conservatives’ now,” 27 May 2012, Salon.com (https://www.salon.com/2015/05/27/guardians_of_the_new_segregation_the_wicked_truth_about_the_rights_small_government_crusade/).

[12] Rhae Lynn Barnes and Keri Leigh Merritt, “A Confederate Flag at the Capitol Summons America’s Demons,” Action News Now, 8 January 2021 (https://www.actionnewsnow.com/content/national/573551792.html?ref=792)

[13] Am I saying all Trump supporters are racists? No. Some voted for him for tax breaks, others because they are anti-choice and maybe there were other reasons. But, they all were willing to tolerate racism to achieve their goals. To them I say three words – Babies. In. Cages.

[14] For my Black readers, I know this has certainly NOT been under the surface for you.

[15] Frank Rich, “The Trashing of the Republic: The only response to the carnage in Washington is to banish Trump and his traitorous collaborators from civil society,” 8 January 2021, New York Magazine (https://nymag.com/intelligencer/article/trump-trashing-of-the-american-republic.html). I am echoing many of Frank’s thoughts from this well-written piece. 

[16] Ibram X. Kendi, How to be an Antiracist (New York: One World, 2019).

[17] If you want to fight me on this, you’d better be prepared with the data, the facts, and supportive documents. I am a genealogist and isn’t documented it isn’t true.

AP Photo/Andrew Harnick

AP Photo/Andrew Harnick

January 1, 2021: New Beginnings

Hi peeps! As Jack said, “I’m baaaaack!”

You may have noticed (or not) that I took a break from my weekly blogging. Lots of reasons, not the least of which was the shit-show that 2020 became. From the pandemic, to the ridiculous anti-maskers, to the continuing fight for liberty, justice, and freedom for our Black brothers and sisters, to the election, to the continuing sedition from the GOP, and on and on my mind couldn’t focus on writing about genealogy. I’ve been obsessed with these things (and more), probably to the detriment of my mental-health.[1] But this is a new year and while I don’t intend to leave behind the important issues of today, I find I can turn more easily to the issues and people of the past. 

So, here goes.

During my hiatus, I “discovered” a new source for my German ancestors from the southern and southeastern part of the Pfalz region in Rhineland-Palatinate, Germany: The Birkenhördt Project.[2] They describe themselves as a “non-commercial project committed to documenting all genealogical relationships in the Southern Palatinate and French district of Bas-Rhin.” They’ve been around for 20 years and online since 2004. Can’t comprehend why I just now found them. The database they have compiled includes over 460,000 individuals comprising over 150,000 families.[3] Through this website, I have “found” two pairs of my 8th great-grandparents!

Anyone who knows me, knows why I put found in quotation marks. While the good folks at The Birkenhördt Project are committed to “documenting” relationships, there are no actual documents attached to any of the people and families in their website. 

Ugh.  

No document = no fact. 

 Does that mean I have ignored the info they have? Not at all. What it means is that I have attached a huge grain of salt to all of it. Boulder-size, you might say.

 Undeterred, I’ve gone back to the skills I learned in all my genealogy classes and work on confirming what I can and building from there.

 As it stands now, I have found documented evidence back to my 5th great-grandparents, Johannes Valenin Glesgen, Maria Katharina Becker, Johannes Nikolas Klein, and Maria Eva Mayer and my 6th great-grandparents Johannes Adam Schilling, Lucia Hentgen, Johannes Valenini Müller and Anna Eva Thines.[4] All from the quaint little village of Wernersberg, Rhineland-Palatinate, Germany.[5]

 What a great way to start 2021!

_____________________________________________

[1] Maybe not without reason.

[2] The Birkenhördt Project (http://www.birkenhoerdt.net)

[3] Ibid.

[4] Thank you, FamilySearch.org, for the Catholic Church records from 1688-1786 that are online. If you are listening, get the ones from 1786 forward online ASAP!

[5] I’m so going there when we can safely travel again.

Wernersberg, Bavaria. Photograph by Thomas Schimmele (https://www.fotocommunity.de/photo/wernersberg-thomas-schimmele/38054993).

Wernersberg, Bavaria. Photograph by Thomas Schimmele (https://www.fotocommunity.de/photo/wernersberg-thomas-schimmele/38054993).

Week 35: Unforgettable #52Ancestors

“Unforgettable.”  Meaning: memorable; incapable of being forgotten; remarkable; and, notable.[1] Looking from the outside at my family tree, no one meets that criteria.[2] Looking from the inside, everyone meets that criteria. 

My husband’s third great-grandparents, William and Philis (Chandler) Bryant, lived in the village of Padbury, Buckinghamshire, England, where like most of his neighbors, he worked as an “agricultural laborer.” Two of their seven children emigrated to Nebraska, including my husband’s second great-grandfather. The youngest of the family, Hannah, seems to have had a really tough life and she strikes me as an “unforgettable” person. I am hampered a bit in researching Hannah due to the pandemic because my local Family History Library is closed and the church records for Buckinghamshire can only be accessed there. Nevertheless, there are other records that tell me about Hannah’s life and hers is a story worth telling.

 While the parish of Padbury comprises about 2,000 acres, over three-quarters are farms. The village is small consisting of basically a single “Main” street (named that), with some small off-shoots, including “Old End” where the Bryants lived.[3] In 1841, the year after Hannah’s birth, its population was around 696. Today, it has only grown by about 100 people and many homes in the village look much like they would have back in the day.[4] Old End in particular has several 17th-18th century cottages and houses with thatched roofs.[5]

 At ten-years-old, Hannah helped the family make ends meet by working as a lace maker. A well-established trade in England, one of the main centers of lacemaking in the East Midlands of England, including Buckinghamshire.[6]“Bobbin” lacemaking can be traced back to before 1600.[7] By 1809, Buckinghamshire lace was referred to as English “Lille” because of its similarities to French lace from Lille, Flanders.[8] Of the 345 females living in Padbury in 1851, eighty-one of them worked as lace makers.[9] By 1900, machine lace dominated the industry and most of the handmade lace industry disappeared.[10] Even during Hannah’s time, lacemaking must not have brought much money into the family as many of the lace makers in Padbury lived in households where the head was a “pauper.”[11]

 I next find Hannah in the 1861 census. Still employed as a lace maker, Hannah was living in the Buckingham workhouse with her two-year-old daughter, Agnes.[12] The census shows eighty people of all ages living in the workhouse, exactly half males and half females. Most of the men were elderly, but still working as “Ag Laborers.” The children, fifteen and under were listed as “scholars.” Of the twenty-seven women (ages nineteen and older), eleven worked as lace makers like Hannah. Nine of the women living there were unmarried mothers of small children.[13]

 One of seven in the county of Buckinghamshire, the Buckingham Union Workhouse was built in 1838 and designed to accommodate 125 people.[14] Life in a workhouse was highly regimented as the Poor Law Commissioners established daily routines, a uniform, regular worship services, etc.[15] From March to September, the “inmates” rose at six a.m. and began work at seven. They had one hour for dinner and then would resume work until six p.m. In the winter, they were allowed an extra hour to sleep in the morning.[16] For children, like Agnes, the workhouse was required by law to provide at least three hours of schooling each day, but the quality of this education was poor and inconsistent. Also (and unsurprisingly), while girls learned the “Three Rs” their “education” primarily consisted of needlework, knitting, and “domestic employment.”[17]

So how did Hannah wind up at a workhouse? Both of her parents had died within three months of each other two years earlier and I can find only three of her siblings still alive: brother John in Nebraska; sister Elizabeth married with children; and, unmarried sister Fanny living with Elizabeth as their “house servant.”[18] I very much doubt that Hannah and Agnes would have been accepted by her family and, as such were relegated to the workhouse. 

 Things don’t seem to have improved much for Hannah over the next few years: Agnes likely died and Hannah had two more children out of wedlock – Joseph and William. She married Henry Smith in 1869, but it is unclear to me whether Joseph and William were his sons. Despite being married, in 1871 Hannah and her children Joseph, William, and John (her first child with Henry) again lived at the Buckingham workhouse.[19] Not enumerated with his family, I have not been able to locate Henry in 1871. Instead of lace maker, Hannah worked as a laundress, likely for the workhouse. A bit more crowded than in 1861, the Buckingham workhouse housed fifty-five males and sixty-three females. Again, the most of the woman worked as lace makers.[20]

 Hannah and Henry must have reconnected by 1877 because Hannah gave birth to their second child, Annie, in November of that year. I suspect they may have continued to live at the workhouse because Henry died there four years later.[21]

 Despite her husband’s death, life may have improved for Hannah by the time I find her in the 1881 census: she was living on “Old End” back in Padbury, with her four children and an aunt, Ann Bryant.[22] Her sons, including eleven-year-old John are all “ag laborers” and she and Aunt Ann made lace. In the next village of Steeple Claydon, an old Padbury neighbor of Hannah’s lived Allen Bandy, his wife Ann and five children. Ann died that same summer and perhaps because they knew each other growing up, Hannah and Allen marry in the fall of 1882.[23]

 I feel like Hannah finally achieved some stability in her life. Nine-years later, Allen was an agricultural laborer, but Hannah didn’t need to work anymore and the couple had two children together, Ellen (1883) and George (1884). [24] I haven’t been able to determine what happened to Hannah’s other children so I am hoping that when I can get back to the Family Search Library, I will be able to figure this out.

 By the turn of the century, Allen worked as a “cattleman on farm” which I’m guessing was an improvement from mere “ag laborer.”[25] Allen passed away in 1903 and Hannah six years later.[26]

 Perhaps Hannah didn’t do anything notable or notorious in her life, but she survived sixty-nine years during a time that was not terribly hospitable to poor women. Truly unforgettable.

 


[1] Merriam-Webster online dictionary (http://www.merriam-webster.com : accessed 12 September 2020), “unforgettable.”

[2] With the notable exception of Abraham Lincoln who may be my husband’s fourth cousin, four times removed.

[3] “Parishes: Padbury,” A History of the County of Buckingham: Volume 4, William Page. Ed. (London: Victoria County History, 1927), 209-215; digital publication, British History Online (http://www.british-history.ac.uk/vch/bucks/vol4/pp209-215 : accessed 17 September 2020).

[4] “Padbury,” City Population (https://www.citypopulation.de/en/uk/southeastengland/buckinghamshire/E34003795__padbury/ : accessed 15 September 2020).

[5] “Parishes: Padbury.” 

[6] “Buckinghamshire lace,” Britannica (https://www.britannica.com/art/Buckinghamshire-lace

: accessed 26 September 2020).

[7] “Britain: Honiton, Bucks Point, Bedfordshire, Torchon,” The Lace Guild (https://web.archive.org/web/20140713035959/http://www.laceguild.org/craft/britain.html#bucks :accessed 15 September 2020).

[8] “Buckinghamshire lace,” Britannica.

[9] 1851 census of England, Buckinghamshire, Padbury, folio 287, 5-38; PRO HO 107/193633; digital images, Ancestry (http://www.ancestry.com : accessed 15 September 2020). “GB Historical GIS/University of Portsmouth, Padbury AP/CP through time/Population Statistics/Males and Females,” A Vision of Britain Through Time (https://www.visionofbritain.org.uk/unit/10217970/cube/GENDER : accessed 15 September 2020).

[10] “Britain: Honiton, Bucks Point, Bedfordshire, Torchon,” The Lace Guild.

[11] 1851 census of England, Buckinghamshire, Padbury.

[12] 1861 census of England, Buckinghamshire, Buckingham, folio 12, 18, Hannah and Agnes Bryant in Buckingham Union Workhouse; digital images, Ancestry (http://www.ancestry.com : accessed 15 September 2020).

[13] Ibid.

[14] “Buckingham, Buckinghamshire,” The Workhouse (http://www.workhouses.org.uk/Buckingham/ : accessed 15 September 2020). This is a terrific website. He has a lot of great pictures of the Buckingham Workhouse, but restricts their use, so I cannot show you them. Sadly, he has slapped a lot of copyright notices on many of the images on his site that are clearly not his original work.

[15] “Workhouse Life,” The Workhouse.

[16] Ibid.

[17] “Education in the Workhouse,” The Workhouse.

[18] FreeBMD, “England & Wales, Civil Registration Death Index, 1837-1915,” entry for William Bryant, Buckingham, vol. 3a, p. 332 (Jul-Aug-Sep, 1859); digital image, Ancestry (http://www.ancestry.com : accessed 15 September 2020). FreeBMD, “England & Wales, Civil Registration Death Index, 1837-1915,” entry for Phillis Bryant, Buckingham, vol. 3a, p. 332 (Jul-Aug-Sep, 1859); digital image, Ancestry (http://www.ancestry.com : accessed 15 September 2020). 1861 census of England, Buckinghamshire, Padbury, folio 128:3, abode 12, Thomas and Elizabeth Gibbs, children, and Fanny Briant; digital images, Ancestry (http://www.ancestry.com : accessed 15 September 2020). U.S. census, Douglas County, Nebraska Territory, p. 582, John Bryant; digital image, Ancestry (http://www.ancestry.com : accessed 15 September 2020).

[19] 1871 census of England, Buckinghamshire, Buckingham, folio 12, lines 21-21, Hannah, Joseph, William and John Smith in Buckingham Union Workhouse; digital images, Ancestry (http://www.ancestry.com : accessed 15 September 2020).

[20] Ibid.

[21] FreeREG (https://www.freereg.org.uk/search_records/5817ae2fe93790ec7543b192/henry-smith-burial-buckinghamshire-leckhampstead-1881-01-18?locale=en : accessed 15 September 2020), parish register burial entry for Henry Smith, 18 January 1181, Leckhampstead, Buckinghamshire; citing St. Mary the Virgin, reg. no. 660, file line no. 991. 

[22] 1881 census of England, Buckinghamshire, Padbury, folio 131:18, abode 112, Hannah Smith; digital images, Ancestry (http://www.ancestry.com : accessed 15 September 2020).

[23] FreeBMD, “England & Wales, Civil Registration Marriage Index, 1837-1915,” entry for Allen Bandy, Buckingham, vol. 3a, p. 1017; digital image, Ancestry (http://www.ancestry.com : accessed 15 September 2020).

[24] 1891 census of England, Buckinghamshire, Steeple Claydon, folio 76:6, abode 43, Allen Bandy; digital images, Ancestry (http://www.ancestry.com : accessed 15 September 2020).

[25] 1901 census of England, Buckinghamshire, Steeple Claydon, folio 91:9, abode 69, Allen Bandy; digital images, Ancestry (http://www.ancestry.com : accessed 15 September 2020).

[26] FreeBMD, “England & Wales, Civil Registration Death Index, 1837-1915,” entry for Hannah Bandy, Aylesbury, vol. 3a, p. 386 (October, November, December 1909); digital image, Ancestry (http://www.ancestry.com : accessed 15 September 2020). FreeBMD, “England & Wales, Civil Registration Death Index, 1837-1915,” entry for Allen Bandy, Aylesbury, vol. 3a, p. 437 (April, May, June 1903); digital image, Ancestry (http://www.ancestry.com : accessed 15 September 2020).

The Buckingham Workhouse was designed by Sir George Gilbert Scott.  “Workhouse, Buckingham,” GilbertScott.org (https://gilbertscott.org/workhouse-buckingham/ : accessed 16 September 2020).

The Buckingham Workhouse was designed by Sir George Gilbert Scott. “Workhouse, Buckingham,” GilbertScott.org (https://gilbertscott.org/workhouse-buckingham/ : accessed 16 September 2020).

“Padbury, cottage in Lower Way,” taken 2006, copyright by Kevin Quick (http://www.countyviews.com/bucks/vipages2/padbury7.html)

“Padbury, cottage in Lower Way,” taken 2006, copyright by Kevin Quick (http://www.countyviews.com/bucks/vipages2/padbury7.html)

Layout of the workhouse.

Layout of the workhouse.

Week 34: Chosen Family #52Ancestors

Nineteen years ago, the world changed forever. 

 Nineteen years ago, 2,977 people died and more than 6,000 were injured.

 Nineteen years ago, roughly 150 members of Congress came together on the front steps of the Capitol broke into an impromptu rendition of “God Bless America.”

 Nineteen years ago, these leaders stood strong and united and provided inspiration to the Nation. 

 That is the family I choose.

 Peace, my brothers and sisters.

 

The Tribute in Light, a memorial for the World Trade Center attacks on 9/11, is seen from the Staten Island Postcards 911 Memorial. (Jeff Bachner/for New York Daily News)

The Tribute in Light, a memorial for the World Trade Center attacks on 9/11, is seen from the Staten Island Postcards 911 Memorial. (Jeff Bachner/for New York Daily News)

Week 33: Black Sheep #52Ancestors

I’ve mentioned before what “unadventurous” Glacy ancestors I have. After coming to the U.S. from Germany, they never left the East Coast until somewhat recently.[1] However, there was one exception to that rule: my first cousin, once removed, Joseph Anthony Glacy.[2] Born in Brooklyn in 1899, Joe found his place all over the world as a magician, mentalist, showman, and promoter. Personally, I think a book needs to be written about his life, but for now I hope you enjoy this over-due (and overly-long) post.

Joe’s mother died in 1902 when he was two and she just twenty-two.[3] According to a story about Joe published in Billboard magazine, Joe recalled that the owner of the apartment building where his family lived, a man named Gus Burkhardt, took a personal interest in him, teaching him some basic magic tricks.[4] Although likely not the owner of the apartment building, a Gus and Julia Burkhart lived in the same building as Joe’s family for several years and in the neighborhood for many more. The census records show Gus was a bartender and magician, among other jobs.[5] 

According to the Billboard story, Joe’s father supported his career choice and advertised his son as “The Boy Wonder.” A 1914 clipping from The Chat, a Brooklyn newspaper, recounts how fourteen-year-old Joe performed for the fiftieth birthday celebration of Frank Krug.[6] Joe’s bio in Billboard describes performances by Joe at the Union Square Theater in New York, Coney Island, and at venues shows in the New York City area. By the time he was nineteen, Joe was referred to in the Brooklyn newspaper as a “well-known” magician.[7] Also by that time, Joe had married and had an infant son. Joe and Margaret Biesel were married 22 October 1917 in New York City and their son, Lawrence Joseph, was born in June the following year.[8]

In 1920, Joe belonged to “The Wizards,” a New York group of professional magicians connected to the “Secret Association of American Magicians.[9] However, he was not enumerated with his wife and son on the 1920 Federal census; Margie and Lawrence were living with her mother.[10] Sometime shortly thereafter, Joe and Margie were divorced and Joe moved to California where, on October 1, 1926 at twenty-six years-old, he married for a second time. His second wife, Elenore Edna Roberts, also an “entertainer” and also previously married.[11]

From the early-1920’s onward, Joe made his living as a magician and managing various side-shows at carnivals in California, the Pacific Northwest, Hawai’i, Australia, and the Philippines. In 1932, Joe and sixteen others were arrested in Honolulu in order to test the legal status of a “Bingo” game that Joe ran.[12] Presumably he paid the one dollar fine for gambling.[13]

As a “famous” barker, Joe and three others were signed in 1933 to perform in Clara Bow’s film, “Hoopla.”[14] Bow’s character, a “hootchy-kootchy” dancer at a carnival, seduces the son of the show’s manager.[15] Born in Brooklyn like Joe, Bow was the first “It Girl.”[16] She started out in silent pictures and by 1928 was the highest-paid movie star in Hollywood receiving $35,000 a week.[17] She appeared in forty-six silent films and eleven “talkies.”[18] “Hoopla” was her final film before she retired at age twenty-eight.[19] Apparently, neither Joe nor any of the other barkers are credited in the film, so I am going to have to find it somewhere and see for myself![20]

With all his travels, it is no wonder that Joe and his wife Edna divorced in the early 1930’s.[21] By the late 1930’s Joe settled down in the Los Angeles area. Beginning in 1936, Billboard magazine regularly mentioned Joe and his acts in the “Carnival” or “Circus” pages.[22] Joe’s specialty at that time included a side-show featuring oddities and “freaks.” In 1936, he managed the “Strange as It Seems” show for John Hix. The Hix show claimed not to have anything “gruesome,” but featured “Big Bertha” and “Slim Jim,” the world’s largest wife and thinnest husband, a trained flea circus, a leopard-skin man, a three-foot tall woman, a female sword-swallower, and other “curious inanimate objects.”[23] I remember as a kid seeing Hix’s syndicated comic strip in the local paper. Competing with Ripley’s Believe it or Not! cartoons, Hix required that every fact published be verified by a minimum of three sources.[24] Now, there’s my kind of researcher!

One of Joe’s side-show attractions in 1936 was Carolina Rascon, “Mexico’s Glamorous Giantess.”[25] At nearly seven and one-half feet tall, it was reported she had the strength of Hercules with the features of beauty and a sweet personality.[26] At eighteen, Carolina left Mexico with her mother hoping to “capitalize” on her size by either appearing in films or by “going on exhibition.”[27] While it all seems so cruel now, I can only hope she found Joe to be a good boss.[28]

At various points, the “Glacy Side Show” also featured a Gorilla Woman.[29] I remember my mom would take us kids to a local county fair that had a tent featuring similar kinds of “oddities.” None of my siblings remember this, but I recall that I begged her to let us go inside. Of course she said “no.” She was a good mom.

By 1942, Long Beach became Joe’s permanent headquarters although he still took his shows up and down the West Coast and to Hawai’i. He lived near and worked at “The Pike” an amusement zone along the ocean in Long Beach. As the homeport of the Pacific Fleet, thousands of sailors visited The Pike and enjoyed the many amusements there including Joe’s sideshow.[30] Known as “The Coney Island of the West,” Joe must have felt he was home at last.[31] Indeed, Joe seems to have stayed in the Long Beach area until his death in 1965.

But wait! I’m jumping the gun. Lots more to tell about Joe – I warned you this would be a long one.

When the Second World War started for the U.S., Joe was the President of the Pacific Coast Showmen’s Association. Joe joined the PCSA in 1924 when he first came out to California. Founded only the year before, the PCSA was a chapter of the Showmen’s League of America whose first president was “Buffalo Bill” Cody.[32] The mission of the SLA and PCSA was to care for carnival workers who were ill or destitute and to provide burial services for members (and even some non-members).[33] When interviewed in Billboard in 1950, Joe expressed his love and gratitude to the PCSA where he also served as vice-president, chair of the charity banquet/ball, and on numerous other committees. 

Joe and his fellow “carnies” continued to ply their trade during World War II. Indeed, because of restrictions on travel and the build-up of the defense industry, The Pike was more crowded than ever and the 1942 Douglas Greater Show, a carnival touring Wenatchee, Washington, enjoyed a 35% increase in attendance and gross from the prior year.[34] Joe was in charge of public relations and radio for Douglas.[35]  This is not to say that the carnies didn’t involve themselves in the war effort. Immediately after the attack on Pearl Harbor, the PCSA, it’s Ladies’ Auxiliary and members came out in force to buy over $60,000 in Defense Bonds.[36] Below you will see a picture from Billboard with Joe and other members of the PCSA with a representative of the National Defense Bond and Stamp drive.[37]

I found an interesting note in the middle of a Billboard article which stated that Joe had joined the Coast Guard in October 1942.[38] Coast Guard records are not on-line nor easily accessed, so I haven’t determined if this is true or not. I find this hard to believe for a couple of reasons: first, at almost forty-four, Joe would have certainly been too old; and, second, Billboard continued to report on his activities with the PCSA all through the war, including trips in the Spring of 1943 to the East Coast and the fact that he was chair of the charity ball in December of 1943.[39] Today you must be younger than thirty-two to join for active duty and under forty to join the reserve.[40] I can well imagine Joe wanting to join, telling his friends he had, but then being unable to serve. 

After the war, The Pike amusements suffered a significant drop: from 35 to 50%.[41] One of the primary reasons for the slump was the closing of the shipyards and other military plants. Despite all that, Joe ramped-up his operations with a new permanent location at The Pike.[42] He advertised for workers including “Freaks, Working Acts, Pitch Acts that can sell, Man or Woman that can sell inside, Sword Box and Feature.”[43] I think we’ve all seen the “Sword Box” trick (assistant in the box stabbed by swords comes out unscathed) and apparently, a “Pitch Act” is a one-person act where all of the props are contained in one suit case. Joe’s ad is directed to the side show people coming off the summer season and he touts his location as having “No ups and downs, no rainy, muddy lots.” In keeping with the guy I have come to know, his ad specifies “No drunks or agitators tolerated.”[44] One of the acts Joe booked for his permanent side show was “Lady Vivian,” a pretty sword swallower.[45]

To catch-up on Joe’s love-life, he married yet again on December 28, 1944.[46] His new wife, Olive Rector, was born in 1909 in Rhode Island to Walter and Hilda (Anderson) Rector. Her father was a soldier who enlisted in the Army in 1902 at nineteen. Sadly, he contracted tuberculosis in the service and died when Olive was four.[47] Olive lived for a time in an orphanage before being reunited with her mother and new step-father.[48] Olive was living in New York City in 1940 just before marrying Joe in California.[49] I don’t know how they met; maybe during one of Joe’s trips to New York for the PCSA or a visit home to his family. Was it love at first sight? It must have been compelling enough for Olive to leave her family and the East Coast and move to California.

In 1945, Joe purchased the Dillinger “crime car” to put it on display. By 1947, he was showing the car at “Crafts 20 Big Show,” a California-based traveling circus, and doing “big biz.”[50] Interesting fact: Crafts 20’s horse carousel was featured in a scene in Alfred Hitchcock’s Strangers on a Train and the 1964 Elvis Presley movie Roustabout.[51] Cool. 

Anyway, back to the “crime car.” It was a 1931 “16-cyl ARMORED Cadillac with bullet-proof glass, steel plate under upholster.”[52] Apparently, it also featured smoke and tear gas generators and a device under the car to spray tacks on the road in order to puncture the tires of any chasing police.[53] Joe devoted a lot of time, energy, and (presumably) money to displaying the car. He built a “rolling exhibit” on a semi-trailer with sides that would open to form a platform for his customers. The trailer was painted an “eye-catching circus red,” of course[54] Joe’s grandson, Lawrence Glacy, recalled as a teenager he sold tickets to the car for 25 cents and that he went with his grandfather when he took the car on tour with a carnival.[55] Lawrence also mentioned that Joe had added a machine gun to the car. 

 Although all of the articles in Billboard indicate Joe was doing well with the car, he started to try to sell three years later.[56] A fellow carnival promoter, W. P. Stephenson, bought the car in 1951.[57] Joe had offered the car, the 30-foot semi, and the Chevy trailer for $5,500. While I don’t doubt that Joe thought the car was authentic, I have only found one reference to Dillinger driving a Cadillac.[58]

 By 1950, Joe had only one attraction left at The Pike – a “Motordrome.” A “Motordrome” is a “circular walled area, usually made of wood, in which motorcycle drivers ride their bikes and do various stunts.”[59] No really. Joe sold tickets to people so that they could drive their motorcycles like maniacs around and around on an angled wooden track. Yikes! Joe had enough common sense that he never personally rode a bike in a drome.[60]

 Joe and Olive lived in Long Beach until about 1951 when they moved to Santa Monica where Olive owned/ran a café called “Marie & Olive’s”.[61] Joe managed rides at the “Kiddytown” at Ocean Park in Santa Monica, an amusement park built over the ocean in 1911.[62] Kiddytown was a complete miniature amusement park cut down to size and just for children.[63]

 Ever the romantic, Joe married again (and for the last time) in 1958. His bride was Irene Alice Yetter and they married in Coeur d’Alene, Idaho on September 19th.[64] Although they married in Idaho, both were Long Beach residents at the time. Did they go there for beautiful scenery or did Joe have a show there? Born in Sandusky, Ohio in 1904, Irene had been married twice before and had one son.[65] Irene and her second husband, George Johnson, moved from the Mid-West to Long Beach sometime in the late 1930’s.[66] George was a car dealer and Irene ran a candy store called “Apple Sweet Shop.” Her store was at The Pike, which is where I am guessing she and Joe met.[67]

 I noticed that Joe and Irene lived at the same address in Long Beach where he and Olive lived when they were married years before. In fact, other than when he lived in Santa Monica for a few years, his home address from1943 to 1965 was 330 W. Ocean Blvd. When I looked up the address in the Long Beach city directory, I found that it was a hotel! Located only a couple of blocks from the beach, The Blackstone Hotel and Apartments overlooked The Pike, which explains why Joe lived there. Built in 1922, the Blackstone’s original owner was Countess Kate Nixon d’Aleria.[68] Now there’s someone else who needs a book written about her! The widow of Nevada banker, gold miner, and U.S. senator who died in 1912. Kate inherited about $2-3 million and married eight years later to Count Adond d’Aleria, a gentleman thirty-years her junior. This post is long-enough already, so I will restrain myself and not tell you her life-story.

 The Blackstone is one of Long Beach’s treasures designated by the city as an historic landmark.[69]  It offered single, double, and twin rooms with baths and the rooms were decorated in either mahogany or ivory.[70] There was a ballroom on the second floor, billiard and card rooms, a sun parlor on each floor, and a basement for seventy-five automobiles.[71]One of its selling features, it was one of the first high-rise buildings in the area built to withstand earthquakes.

 By 1960, Joe had moved his kiddie rides to Pierpoint Landing Long Beach.[72] He appears to have retired from the show business by 1961, and other than attending the 1960 ball/banquet, does not appear to have been active in the Pacific Coast Showmen’s Association.[73]

 Joe died in April of 1965 and he was buried in a mini-cemetery within Evergreen Memorial Park affectionately dubbed the “Showmen’s Rest.”[74] As I noted, the PCSA was a philanthropic service organization and at their founding in 1923 they began buying plots at Evergreen for carnival workers.[75] Since then, about 400 carnies, including Joe, were buried in the Showmen’s Rest. 

 I hope you enjoyed reading about Joe as much as I enjoyed writing about him. If asked, I would say Joe was an adventurous romantic who loved people.

 

P.S. Not surprisingly, the Pacific Coast Showmen’s Association is no more.[76]


[1] Ignoring for the moment how absolutely adventurous it was to cross the Atlantic to make a new home.

[2] I cannot begin to tell you how many “Joseph” Glacys there were (are) in my family.

[3] New York City Deaths, 1892-1902, “Deaths Reported in 1902, Brooklyn,” Theresa Glacy, 5 February 1902, death certificate no. 2490; “New York, New York, Death Index, 1892-1898, 1900-1902,” Ancestry (http://www.ancestry.com : accessed 28 August 2020).

[4] Sam Abbott, “Joe Glacy ‘At Liberty’ Gives Time to His 26-Year Love – PCSA,” The Billboard, 23 September 1950, p. 55, col. 1-2.

[5] 1900 U.S. census, Kings County, New York, population schedule, Brooklyn, enumeration district 444, p. 209A (stamped), p. 24 (penned), dwelling 99, family 555, Gustav Burkhardt (bartender); digital image, Ancestry (http://www.ancestry.com : accessed 5 September 2020). 1905 New York state census, Kings County, population schedule, Brooklyn, p. 59, dwelling 99, Gus Burkhardt (magician); digital image, Ancestry (http://www.ancestry.com : accessed 5 September 2020).

[6] “Mr. Frank Krug,” The (Brooklyn) Chat, 9 May 1914, p. 17, col. 6.

[7] “Geo. Ehlenberger B. S. to Hold Victory Ball,” The (Brooklyn) Chat, 12 April 1919, p. 25, col. 4.

[8] New York City, Office of the City Clerk, “Brooklyn, New York, Marriage License Indexes, 1916-1917,” Glacy-Biesel (22 October 1917); digital image, Ancestry, “New York, New York, Marriage License Indexes, 1907-2018,” (http://www.ancestry.com : accessed 5 September 2020); citing New York City Municipal Archives, New York, New York. New York City Department of Health, “Births Reported in 1918 – Borough of Brooklyn,” Lawrence J. Glacy (10 June); digital image, Ancestry (http://www.ancestry.com : accessed 5 September 2020).

[9] “Wizards Enjoy Chinese Food and American Magic,” The (New York) Evening World, 8 May 1920, p. 2, col. 7.

[10] Ibid.

[11] California Department of Public Health, 1926 Index to Marriages, Williams-Glacy (1 October 1926); digital image, Ancestry “California, County Birth, Marriage, and Death Records, 1849-1980” (http://www.ancestry.com : accessed 5 September 2020). New York City, Office of the City Clerk, “Manhattan, New York, Marriage License Indexes, 1918,” Roberts-Williams (18 January 1918); digital image, Ancestry, “New York, New York, Marriage License Indexes, 1907-2018,” (http://www.ancestry.com : accessed 5 September 2020); citing New York City Municipal Archives, New York, New York.

[12] “17 Arrested to Test Bingo Games,” Honolulu Star-Bulletin, p. 15, col. 6. 

[13] “Appeal Dismissed,” Honolulu Star-Bulletin, p. 2, col. 3. Bingo is still illegal in Hawai’i. “Is Playing Bingo Gambling in the US?,” Bingo.org (https://www.bingo.org/us-bingo-laws/ : accessed 2 September 2020).

[14] “Four ‘Barkers’ Signed,” The Los Angeles Times, 24 September 1933, p. 27, col. 2.

[15] “Hoopla,” IMDb (https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0024139/ : accessed 2 September 2020).

[16] “Clara Bow: Biography,” IMDb (https://www.imdb.com/name/nm0001966/bio?ref_=nm_ov_bio_sm : accessed 2 September 2020).

[17] Ibid.

[18] Wikipedia.org, “Clara Bow,” rev. 21:10, 28 August 2020.

[19] Ibid.

[20] Joe didn’t mention the film in his bio but it was considered a flop, so maybe he didn’t want to bring it up. One of her favorite quotes was “The more I see of men, the more I like dogs.” Present company excluded of course. “Clara Bow Quotes,” BrainyQuote.com (https://www.brainyquote.com/quotes/clara_bow_197931 : accessed 2 September 2020).

[21] I haven’t found the divorce record, but Edna was shown as married in the 1930 census and she married her third husband in 1934.

[22] Too many to cite.

[23] “Strange Attractions to Be Shown in New Fun Zone at Exposition,” San Diego Union, 2 March 1936, p.7.

[24] Wikipedia.org, “Strange as It Seems,” rev. 13:54, 22 August 2020.

[25] Felix Bley, “Along the California Pacific Expo Midway,” The Billboard, 18 April 1936, p. 46, col.1. 

[26] “Jack Starr-Hunt, “Mexico’s Glamorous Giantess,” The (Massillon, Ohio) Evening Independent, p. 7, col. 3-5. 

[27] “Seven-Foot Giantess Orders Golden Taffeta Evening Gown,” The El Paso (Texas) Times, 20 December 1935, p. 2, col. 5-6. 

[28] Remarkably, Carolina was not the first “Mexican Giantess.” A woman with that description was reported to be on exhibition in England in 1868. “Guernsey,” The (London, England) Era, 13 December 1868, p. 12, col. 1.

[29] Carl Foreman, “Huggins’ West Coast,” The Billboard, 10 September 1938, p. 45, col. 4.

[30] D. J. Waldie, “A Walk Along Long Beach’s Gaudy, Tawdry, Bawdy Pike,” 8 February 2017, “Lost LA,” KCET.org (https://www.kcet.org/shows/lost-la/a-walk-along-long-beachs-gaudy-tawdry-bawdy-pike : accessed 1 September 2020).

[31] Jonathan Murrietta, “The Pike: Another Time and Another Place,” Long Beach 908 Magazine, Spring 2017, p. 4-8; digital images, Long Beach 908 Magazine Online (https://www.lb908.com/post/2017/08/16/the-pike-another-time-and-another-place : accessed 1 September 2020)

[32] “About Us,” Showmen’s League of America (http://www.showmensleague.org : accessed 2 September 2020).

[33] Ibid. Lynda Natali, “Life and Death on Midway: Lifestyle: A traveling priest and his wandering congregation celebrate the rituals and traditions of carnival workers,” Los Angeles Times, 12 January 1993; digital image, LATimes.com (https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-1993-01-12-vw-1409-story.html : accessed 1 September 2020). “Pacific Coast Showmen’s Assn.” The Billboard, 22 April 1944, p. 35, col. 3. 

[34] D. J. Waldie, “A Walk Along Long Beach’s Gaudy, Tawdry, Bawdy Pike.” “Douglas Inaugural at Wenatchee Tops 1941 Marks by 35%,” The Billboard, 6 June 1942, p. 28, col. 3.

[35] “Douglas Inaugural,” The Billboard, 6 June 1942, p. 28, col. 3.

[36] “Coast Defense Exec Lauds PCSA’s Work,” The Billboard, 17 January 1942, p. 53, col. 2.

[37] “Prominent Members,” The Billboard, 17 January 1942, p. 32, col 2-3.

[38] “Joe Glacy,” The Billboard, 31 October 1942, p. 57, col. 2.

[39] “Pacific Coast Showmen’s Assn.” The Billboard, 15 May 1943, p. 33, col. 1. “Pacific Coast Showmen’s Assn.” The Billboard, 11 December 1943, p. 33, col. 3. 

[40] “FAQ: What are the qualifications to join the Coast Guard?,” GoCoastGuard.com (https://www.gocoastguard.com/faq : accessed 2 September 2020).

[41] “Long Beach Pike Still Suffering Cash Doldrums,” The Billboard, 1 November 1947, p. 57, col. 1.

[42] Ibid.

[43] “Side Show People – Attention,” The Billboard, 3 August 1946, p. 68, col. 2-3.

[44] Ibid.

[45] “Long Beach Pike,” The Billboard, 1 November 1947, p. 89, col. 2.

[46] “Marriages,” The Billboard, 20 January 1944, p. 33, col. 3.

[47] North Carolina State Board of Health, Division of Labor Statistics, death certificate No. 2464, Walter Rector (1912); digital image, Ancestry(http://www.ancestry.com : accessed 5 September 2020).

[48] 1915 Rhode Island state census, Newport County, population schedule, Newport City, [no p. no.], house no. 24, dwelling no. 123, family no. 177, Olive P. Rector in children’s home; digital image, Ancestry “Rhode Island, State Censuses, 1865-1935” (http://www.ancestry.com : accessed 5 September 2020).

[49] 1940 U.S. census, New York County, New York, population schedule, Manhattan Assembly District 10, p. 3577 (stamped), enumeration district 31-834, sheet 7-A, dwelling 206, family 31, Olive Knotts in household of Hilda Knotts; digital image, Ancestry (http://www.ancestry.com : accessed 5 September 2020).

[50] “Long Beach Notes,” The Billboard, 26 April 1947, p. 85, col. 2.

[51] “More Than Everything You Wanted to Know About Runaway Nightmare and Mike Cartel,” Runaway Nightmare (http://www.runawaynightmare.com/?page_id=235 : accessed 3 September 2020).

[52] “For Sale,” The Billboard, 6 November 1948, p. 60, col. 1-2.

[53] “Desperado’s Car to be Displayed,” The Neosho (Missouri) Daily News, 16 October 1956, p. 1, col. 1.

[54] “Long Beach Notes,” The Billboard, 25 January 1947, p. 71, col. 3.

[55] Jessica Williams Interview with Lawrence Glacy, 18 November 2017, Intrepid Sea, Air & Space Museum (https://intrepidmuseum.libraryhost.com/files/OHP152%20Lawrence%20Glacy%20Oral%20History%20FINAL.pdf : accessed 1 September 2020).

[56] “For Sale,” The Billboard, 6 November 1948, p. 60, col. 1-2.

[57] “Desperado’s Car to be Displayed,” The Neosho (Missouri) Daily News, 16 October 1956, p. 1, col. 1.

[58] “3 Report Seeing Dillinger in Redwood Falls, Trap Set by Federal, Local Officials,” The Redwood (Minnesota) Gazette, 14 June 1934, p. 1, col. 5-6.

[59] A. W. Stencell, Seeing is Believing: America’s Sideshows, “Glossary” (Toronto: ECW Press, 2002), 251.

[60] “Joe Glacy,” The Billboard, 23 September 1950, p. 74, col. 3-4.

[61] R. L. Polk & Co., compiler, Santa Monica City Directory (Los Angeles: R. L. Polk & Co of California, 1953), 166, Joe and Olive Glacy.

[62] R. L. Polk & Co., compiler, Santa Monica City Directory (Los Angeles: R. L. Polk & Co of California, 1953), “Ocean Park,” p. x.

[63] Ted Yerxa, “Along the Fun and Sun Zone, (North Hollywood, California) Valley Times, 25 July 1953, p. 11, col. 7.

[64] Idaho Department of Public Health, Division of Vital Statistics, marriage certificate no. 7005 (1958), Glacy-Johnson (née Yetter); digital image, Ancestry (http://ancestry.com : accessed 3 September 2020).

[65] Erie County, Ohio, Probate Court, Marriage Records, vol. 16 (17 March 1919-21 April 1923), Ruskin-Yetter (1927), p. 540; digital image, Ancestry, “Ohio County Marriage Records, 1774-1993,” (http://ancestry.com : accessed 3 September 2020). “U.S. World War I Draft Registration Cards, 1917-1918, digital image, Ancestry (http://ancestry.com : accessed 3 September 2020), card for George Washington Johnson, serial no. 1280, Local Draft Board, Parkersburg, Wood County, West Virginia. “Funeral is Set Tomorrow for Wapak Doctor,” The (Dayton, Ohio) Journal Herald, p. 3, col. 3.

[66] 1940 U.S. census, Los Angeles County, California, population schedule, Long Beach City, p. [not noted], enumeration district 59050, sheet 6-A, dwelling 1000, family 174, George W. Johnson; digital image, Ancestry (http://www.ancestry.com : accessed 5 September 2020).

[67] R. L. Polk & Co., compiler, Long Beach City Directory (Los Angeles: R. L. Polk & Co of California, 1953), 335, George W. and Irene Johnson.

[68] Claudine Burnett, “The ‘Cougar’ Countess and Long Beach’s Blackstone Apartment Hotel,” Long Beach’s Past, 30 May 2017 (http://historiclongbeach.blogspot.com/2017/05/the-cougar-countess-and-long-beachs.html : accessed 4 September 2020).

[69] Long Beach, California, Municipal Code, §16.52.410 – The Blackstone Hotel (https://library.municode.com/ca/long_beach/codes/municipal_code?nodeId=TIT16PUFAHILA_CH16.52HILA_16.52.410THBLHO : accessed 5 September 2020).

[70] “Blackstone Hotels and Apartments, Waterfront, Long Beach, CA,” Pacific Coast Architecture Database (http://pcad.lib.washington.edu/building/1951/ : accessed 4 September 2020).

[71] Ibid.

[72] Al Flint, “Pacific Coastliners,” The Billboard, 8 August 1960, p. 58, col. 4.

[73] “PCSA Banquet-Ball Pulls 300 Showfolk,” The Billboard, 26 December 1960, p. 46, col. 3-4.

[74] Find A Grave, database with images (http://www.findagrade.com : accessed 5 September 2020), memorial 7926189, Joseph Anthony Glacy (1899-1965), Evergreen Cemetery, Los Angeles, California; gravestone photograph by Shiver.

[75] Lynda Natali, “Life and Death on Midway.”

[76] Pacific Coast Showmen’s Association Overview,” CorporationWiki (https://www.corporationwiki.com/California/Upland/pacific-coast-showmens-association/39450462.aspx : accessed 3 September 2020). There is an nonprofit organization by that name I have found on Facebook, but I cannot determine its connection to the original group.

Sam Abbott, “Joe Glacy ‘At Liberty’ Gives Time to His 26-Year Love – PCSA,” The Billboard, 23 September 1950, p. 55, col. 1-2.

Sam Abbott, “Joe Glacy ‘At Liberty’ Gives Time to His 26-Year Love – PCSA,” The Billboard, 23 September 1950, p. 55, col. 1-2.

Joe and Olive at the 1945 PCSA Ball. "At the P.C.S.A. Ball," The Billboard, 29 December 1945, p. 47.

Joe and Olive at the 1945 PCSA Ball. "At the P.C.S.A. Ball," The Billboard, 29 December 1945, p. 47.

Carolina Rascon and friends. “Mexican Amazon Dwarfs El Pasoans,”  El Paso (Texas) Times, 19 December 1935,  p. 1, col. 5-6.

Carolina Rascon and friends. “Mexican Amazon Dwarfs El Pasoans,” El Paso (Texas) Times, 19 December 1935, p. 1, col. 5-6.

The Pike. The Blackstone is the shorter white building in front of the high-rise.

The Pike. The Blackstone is the shorter white building in front of the high-rise.

Allegedly, this is Lady Vivian, the sword swallower (1920-30). “I’m Still Here!!,” The Ritzy Flapper (http://theritzyflapper.blogspot.com/2012/12/ : accessed 4 September 2020).

Allegedly, this is Lady Vivian, the sword swallower (1920-30). “I’m Still Here!!,” The Ritzy Flapper (http://theritzyflapper.blogspot.com/2012/12/ : accessed 4 September 2020).

Week 32: Small #52 Ancestors

Sometimes a small but overlooked piece of information can change everything.

I have been working on this blog for some weeks now. I know, I know – I am late and way behind our fearless leader, Amy Johnson Crow. I’ve had serious writers-block all summer.

Any-who, I was looking into the Elliott and Field families who are ancestors of my husband with the intention of writing about them when I got caught down a rabbit-hole. I kept coming across Lewis J. Field and I just couldn’t figure out how he fit in with the family. I knew that he had to connect somehow since he settled in Effingham County, Illinois near all the other Fields and Elliotts I knew were ancestors. Yet, for the life of me, I just couldn’t make the connection.

As with anything that seems impossible, the advice is always to tackle it like you would eat an elephant: one bite at a time.

I started with Lewis and dove into his life. I discovered that in 1866 his daughter, Mary Frances Field married Thomas Jefferson Dunn, a grandson of Elijah Elliott, who I knew was my husband’s fourth great-grandfather. While that is an Elliott-Field connection, it is just not the one I was looking for. You see, it was actually Lewis’ father Ambrose who initially settled in Illinois so the family connection had to pre-date Mary and Thomas’ marriage. 

Since the family connection was clear with Thomas and Mary, I started with them and worked my way back, building that family tree brick by brick:

·      Mary Frances Field was the daughter of Lewis J. Field, MD and Frances T. Conrey.[1]

·      Lewis J. Field, MD, was the son of Ambrose Field and Elizabeth Reeder.[2]

·      Ambrose Field was likely the son of Thomas Field and Lydia Lawrence.

·      Thomas Field was the son of John Field and Margaret Pearl, my husband’s fifth great-grandparents.

 Bingo!

 Not as easy as it looks. You see, I never had Thomas as a son for John and Margaret in my family tree nor any of his descendants until yesterday.

Here’s what I think I learned about Thomas:

Thomas was born about 1770 (plus or minus) in Virginia but only think this because I found a marriage record for him in Fauquier County, VA, dated 1793.[3] But how do I know this is the correct Thomas since the marriage bond does not name his father or mother? [As I have noted before, the biggest trap inexperience (and experienced) researchers fall into is “the name’s the same.” Meaning “this must be my ancestor because it is the same name.” Yeah, not so much.] I did some collateral research and found that the probable sisters of Thomas (Polly and Elander aka “Nelly”) were married in 1793 and 1798, respectively, in Fauquier County and Polly’s marriage return identifies her father as John.[4]

Okay that makes sense, but is it enough? 

Of course not.

Then I “discovered” a document that I already had that closed this loop. Silly me.

Several years ago (maybe more like “many”) I grabbed a document from another Field tree that mentioned John Field, his wife Margaret and some of their children. I didn’t pay much attention to it at the time – it must have been one of those days when I wasn’t too terribly focused (“Squirrel!”). Going back to it now made me slap my forehead. This small and overlooked document turned out to be just one page of many that provided a wealth of information and tied Thomas to my husband’s ancestors.

Long story short: For some reason that I have yet to discover, John and Margaret Field wound up being indebted to a Mary Howell for $420. Their son-in-law Thomas Power (Polly’s husband) and son William acted as sureties and John and Margaret sold all of their personal property to Thomas and William for $1,000.[5]  However, because they had used real estate bequeathed to Margaret by her father to buy that personal property, they needed to list all of their heirs.[6]

Hot dog!

Not only did these documents confirm that Margaret’s father was William Pearl, but it named all their living children, including the elusive Thomas. And to think I had ignored this small piece of paper when it opened so many doors for me.

SMDH


[1] Edgar County, Illinois, Marriage Register A:168, Lewis J. Fields and Frances Conrey, 3 February 1842; digital image, FamilySearch (http://familysearch.com : accessed 24 August 2020), FHL microfilm 4,661,387, image 697 of 737.

1860 U.S. census, Effingham County, Illinois, population schedule, Township 6 Range 6E, p. 1107 (penned), dwelling 1145, family 1148, L.J. Field; digital image, Ancestry (http://www.ancestry.com : accessed 25 August 2020); citing NARA microfilm publication M653, roll not noted.

[2] Effingham County, Illinois, Marriage Register 1:113, Louis J. Fields and Hannah Wooley, 11 Jan 1885; digital image, FamilySearch (http://familysearch.com : accessed 24 August 2020), FHL microfilm 4,661,378, image 121 of 513.

[3] Fauquier County, Virginia, Marriage Bonds and Returns, No. 1, 1759-1800, page 404, marriage bond for Thomas Fields and Lydia Lawrence, 25 November 1793; digital image, FamilySearch (http://familysearch.com : accessed 24 August 2020), FHL microfilm 7,578,972, image 232 of 688.

[4] Fauquier County, Virginia, Marriage Bonds and Returns, No. 1, 1759-1800, page 397, marriage bond for Thomas Power and Polly Field, 9 September 1793; digital image, FamilySearch (http://familysearch.com : accessed 24 August 2020), FHL microfilm 7,578,972, image 228 of 688. Fauquier County, Virginia, Marriage Bonds and Returns, No. 2, 1795-1805, page 144, marriage bond for Henry Henderson and Nelly Fields, 31 October 1798; digital image, FamilySearch (http://familysearch.com : accessed 24 August 2020), FHL microfilm 7,578,972, image 338 of 688.

[5] Including two slaves named Ralph and Minna.

[6] Bracken County, Kentucky, Deed Book C:346-7, Thomas Power and William Field agreement with John Field, 8 December 1804; digital images, FamilySearch (http://familysearch.com : accessed 24 August 2020), FHL microfilm 7,900,758 images 200-01 of 604. Bracken County, Kentucky, Deed Book C:350-1, Thomas Power and William Field agreement with John Field, 8 December 1804; digital images, FamilySearch (http://familysearch.com : accessed 24 August 2020), FHL microfilm 7,900,758 images 202-3 of 604.

 

Lewis J. Field, MD. William Henry Perrin, ed., History of Effingham County, Illinois (Illustrated) (Chicago: O.L. Basken & Co., 1883), 171; digital image, Google Books (http://play.google.com : accessed 25 August 2020).

Lewis J. Field, MD. William Henry Perrin, ed., History of Effingham County, Illinois (Illustrated) (Chicago: O.L. Basken & Co., 1883), 171; digital image, Google Books (http://play.google.com : accessed 25 August 2020).

Week 31: Large #52Ancestors

My hometown of Maplewood, NJ, comprises less than four square-miles, so when I moved to the Midwest thirty years ago it took some time to adjust to the wide-open spaces and the vastness of the country. I was reminded of how large our country is this weekend as my husband and I drove to Colorado for a change of scene during quarantine. His car has a huge dash-board screen and you can get Google Earth for the navigation view. I was captivated by the view along I-70 where the landscape still shows many of the Section lines marked out over a century ago by the federal government. 

Before we can talk about how the land was divided for the white settlers, it is important to address the treatment of the Native Americans who once called Kansas home. The Arapaho, Cheyenne, Comanche, Kansa, Kiowa, Osage, Pawnee, and Wichita were the native peoples in present-day Kansas.[1] Additionally, from 1803 onward, the U.S. government sought to resettle Eastern tribes to a designated “Indian Territory” in Kansas order to make way for white settlement in the East. Under the Indian Removal Act of 1830, treaties were made with more than twenty-five tribes to “remove” them to west of the Mississippi, including the Chippewa, Delaware, Kickapoo, Ottawa, Potawatomi, Shawnee, and Wyandotte.[2]  While the Act authorized “negotiated” treaties, the truth was that these were force removals, culminating in the infamous “Trail of Tears” where 60,000 Native Americans were forced to relocate to reservations in Kansas.[3]

While Kansas was initially determined to be unsuitable for white settlement, that didn’t last long and whites began to illegally squat on native lands. Although the tribes had been assured by the federal government that they would not be moved again, the Kansas Territory opened for white settlement in 1854 which once again forced the removal of the native peoples.[4] Tied up in all of this was the impending Civil War and the push to determine if Kansas would be a free or slave state.

The Homestead Act of 1862, enacted during the Civil War, accelerated the settlement of the West by granting adult heads of families 160 acres of surveyed public land for a minimal filing fee and five-years of continues residence on that land.[5]However, most of the 500 million acres dispersed by the Bureau of Land Management between 1862 and 1904 actually went to speculators, cattlemen, miners, lumbermen, and railroads.[6] The BLM’s General Land Office utilized a “Rectangular Survey System” whereby the land was divided first into Townships containing approximately 23,040 acres, measuring approximately six-miles on each side. The Township was then divided into thirty-six Sections, each containing approximately 640 acres. Each Section was further subdivided into halves and quarters and so on. 

In 1854, Kansas was divided “into 25 ranges east and 43 ranges west of the 6th principal meridian ….  Laterally, Kansas was divided into 6-mile squares called townships, which are numbered from 1 to 35, going south from the Nebraska border. Each township is further divided into 36 sections that are one-mile square.”[7] My husband’s second great-grandfather, George Washington Baty, was the first Baty to settle in Kansas when he purchased eighty acres in 1875 in Neosho County, Kansas, described thusly:

The West half (W ½) of the North West quarter (NW ¼) of Section Twenty-eight (28) Town Twenty-eight (28) South of Range Eighteen (18) east Containing Eighty (80) acres according to the Government survey.[8]

 125 years later, my husband and I moved to Johnson County, Kansas.[9] We’ve both lived here longer than any other place in our lives and I thought it might be fun to figure out how and when our property wound up in our hands.

 The land upon which our house sits was originally owned by the Shawnee Nation who had been removed to Kansas from the East.[10] In 1854, the U.S. government entered into an agreement with the tribe whereby the tribe conveyed to the U.S. all of the country lying west of the State of Missouri which had been previously set aside for the Shawnee Nation in 1825 (approximately 16,000 acres).[11] The U.S. agreed to pay the Shawnee people $700,000 (among other provisions).[12]

 According to the GRO survey, our one-third of an acre is located in the North East quarter of Section Thirty-six (36), Township Thirteen (13), South of Range Twenty-four (24) east.[13] This quarter-section was part of a 1,400-acre allotment to James Keizer, his wife Sally, and their five children. Per the 1854 treaty with the Shawnee, members of the tribe were allotted two-hundred acres per person and in 1857, the Keizer family were tribal members so acquired land in Johnson and Wyandotte counties.[14]

 The 1865 Kansas census tells me that James and Sally were born in Ohio.[15] The Shawnee tribe in Ohio had been relegated to the Wapakoneta and Hog Creek reservations after the War of 1812 but then they were forcibly moved to Kansas in 1830 when James was thirteen and Sally was nine.[16]

 Our quarter-section was specifically allotted to Louisa Keizer, one of James and Sally’s daughters.[17] Louisa sold her North East quarter section to Matthias Kershner on 15 July 1867.[18] Kershner also bought James’ property as well as property directly from the Johnson County government in and around that same time.[19]

 I don’t have access to the records after 1867 that would tell me who owned the land next.[20] The earliest map I can find of Township 13 (aka “Shawnee Township”) is dated 1886 and it shows that the North East quarter of Section 36 was owned by L.W. Breyfogle who also owned the adjoining 160 acres of the North West quarter of Section 35.[21] A 1922 map of Johnson County also shows that Breyfogle owned the North East quarter of Section 36.[22] Lewis and his family came from Ohio and were some of the founding families of Overland Park, Kansas. 

I hope you enjoyed this little exploration of Western settlement. 


[1] “American Indians in Kansas,” Kansas Historical Society (https://www.kshs.org/kansapedia/american-indians-in-kansas/17881 : accessed 10 Aug 2020).

[2] “Indian Removal Act,” Kansas Historical Society (https://www.kshs.org/kansapedia/indian-removal-act/16714 : accessed 10 August 2020).

[3] Wikipedia.org, “Trail of Tears,” rev. 22:00, 10 July 2020. 

[4] “American Indians in Kansas,” Kansas Historical Society.

[5] “Homestead Act (1862),” Our Documents (https://www.ourdocuments.gov/doc.php?flash=false&doc=31 :accessed 10 August 2020).

[6] Ibid.

[7] “Kansas Civil Townships and Independent Cities,” Kansas Historical Society (https://www.kshs.org/p/kansas-civil-townships-and-independent-cities/11308 : accessed 12 February 2017).

[8] Neosho County, Kansas, Deed Book 27: 407, George W. Baty and Mary E. Baty to Nathanial W. Lindsey, 14 August 1883; Office of the Register of Deeds, Erie, Kansas.

[9] Thirty years ago this very month.

[10] I don’t know who the U.S. government took this land from in order to “give” it to the Shawnee, but I will have to find out.

[11] “Treaty with the Shawnee, May 10, 1854,” First People (https://www.firstpeople.us/FP-Html-Treaties/TreatyWithTheShawnee1854.html : accessed 10 August 2020).

[12] Ibid.

[13] “Property ID ND54370000 0021,” Johnson County Kansas (https://ims.jocogov.org/locationservices/ : accessed 10 August 2020).

[14] Land Patent to James Keizer, et. al, 28 December 1859, U.S. Department of the Interior, Bureau of Land Management, General Land Office (https://glorecords.blm.gov : accessed 11 August 2020). The patent is dated 1859, but a census shows they acquired the land at or before 1857. 1857 Kansas Territorial Census of Shawnee, p. 72, James Keizer; digital image, “Kansas State Census Collection, 1855-1925,” Ancestry (http://www.ancestry.com: accessed 11 August 2020); citing 1857 Kansas Territorial Censuses, Roll: ks156, Kansas State Historical Society, Topeka.

[15] 1865 Kansas state census, Douglas county, Eudora township, family no. 965, James Kizer; digital image, “Kansas State Census Collection, 1855-1925,” Ancestry (http://www.ancestry.com : accessed 11 August 2020); citing 1865 Kansas Territorial Census, roll: ks1865_3, Kansas State Historical Society, Topeka.

[16] “Shawnee Indians,” Ohio History Connection (https://ohiohistorycentral.org/w/Shawnee_Indians : 11 August 2020).

[17] 1857 Kansas Territorial Census of Shawnee, p. 73, Louisa Keizer; digital image, “Kansas State Census Collection, 1855-1925,” Ancestry(http://www.ancestry.com : accessed 11 August 2020); citing 1857 Kansas Territorial Censuses, Roll: ks156, Kansas State Historical Society, Topeka.

[18] Johnson County, Kansas, Abstract of Shawnee Indian Lands, p. 87,  Kaizer to Kershner (1867); digital image, FamilySearch (http://www.familysearch.org : accessed 12 August 2020), FHL film 8,188,248, image 687 of 791.

[19] Johnson County, Kansas, Deed Index, unpaginated, alphabetical grantee index, 1865-1888; digital image, FamilySearch (http://www.familysearch.org : accessed 12 August 2020), FHL film 8,561,964, image 52 of 860.

[20] They are not available in digital form yet from the Family History Library, so I will have to be patient.

[21] Edwards, John P., Edward's map of Johnson Co., Kansas (Philadelphia: Quincy, Ill.: John P. Edwards, 1886); digital image Library of Congress (https://www.loc.gov/item/2012593084 : accessed 10 August 2020).

[22] Standard Atlas of Johnson County, Kansas (Chicago: Geo. A. Ogle & Co., 1922); digital image, FamilySearch (https://www.familysearch.org : accessed 10 August 2020).

Google map image of I-70 East of Hayes, Kansas showing the Section lines established by the BLM. (https://www.google.com/maps/@38.8985422,-99.3823909,15584m/data=!3m1!1e3).

Google map image of I-70 East of Hayes, Kansas showing the Section lines established by the BLM. (https://www.google.com/maps/@38.8985422,-99.3823909,15584m/data=!3m1!1e3).

E.B. Whitman & A.D. Searl, General Land Agents, “Map of Eastern Kansas” (Boston: J.P. Jewett and Co., 1856); digital image, Kansas Historical Society (http://www.kansasmemory.org/item /213048/page/1 : accessed 10 August 2020).

E.B. Whitman & A.D. Searl, General Land Agents, “Map of Eastern Kansas” (Boston: J.P. Jewett and Co., 1856); digital image, Kansas Historical Society (http://www.kansasmemory.org/item /213048/page/1 : accessed 10 August 2020).

Week 30: The Old Country #52Ancestors

Some months ago, I wrote about the German town where my Glacy (Glaesgen) family originated. This week, I researched Sulzfeld the town where my second great-grandfather, Christopher Götter, came from in 1851.

The second step after you locate the town where your ancestors came from is to consult FamilySearch’s many Wikis. So, for Christopher, I went to “How to Find Birth, Marriage, and Death Records for Baden-Württemberg” and found a step-by-step guide, including how to write a letter to the local parishes to get the documents you need.[1]

 My beginning research focused on U.S. records since I didn’t know where in Germany he originated (your very first and critical step).  The manifest for the ship he arrived on only old me that he came from Baden and that he was a locksmith. 

A quick reminder about German history: “Germany” wasn’t a country until 1918. After the collapse of the Holy Roman Empire in about 1806, various forms of a German nation-states were formed (i.e., the German Confederation and the German Empire). When Christopher immigrated, he wasn’t from Germany, but rather the Grand Duchy of Baden.[2]

It was surprising to find a 1868 baptismal record for Christopher from St. Rose of Lima Church in Springfield, New Jersey.[3] In my very Roman Catholic family, a baptism at forty years of age was unexpected. It didn’t occur to me that his family was anything but Catholic – as nearly all of my ancestors were. This record turned out to be the lynch-pin for my German research because it told me his father’s first name and his mother’s first and maiden name.

My initial research for Christopher’s parents led me to many Lutheran church records in Germany. Initially mystified, it struck me: of course he must have been Lutheran. He married an Irish-Catholic immigrant and most of their six children were baptized at St. Rose. Not sure why it took him thirteen years after his marriage to convert, but it may explain why I haven’t found any church records of their marriage.

Anyway, Ancestry has indexed many German Lutheran church records, but does not have digital images of the records. For that, I had to go to the Archion website.[4] Based in Stuttgart, Archion is a cooperative project with Evangelical Lutheran and protestant churches in Germany to digitize historical records and provide them (for a fee) to the public. Because I wanted to write about Christopher and his family, I sprung for a month-long pass to access their church records. 

Again, it was astounding to see the detail provided by German churches records. Each baptismal, marriage, and burial record provided the names of that person’s parents, sometimes their grandparents, and always their spouse (if married). Many times, you can find three generations identified in one record. Boom!

So, once we can travel again, I’ve got another German town to visit: Sulzfeld, where my Götter and Guggolz family originated.

Sulzfeld a village in the municipality of Sulzfeld in the Karlsruhe district of Baden-Wurttemberg (a state within the Federal Republic of Germany).[5] Its most important attraction is the castle of Ravensburg, first constructed around 930 and last occupied in 1849. Since the 1950’s the remains of the castle have been used for a restaurant and, recently, a wedding chapel. Since about 1252, wine has been grown on the hillsides surrounding the castle and when I go I can visit the Burg Ravensburg both the restaurant and winery. Who’s with me? 


[1] FamilySearch Research Wiki, “How to Find Birth, Marriage, and Death Records for Baden-Württemberg,” rev. 10:32, 26 June 2020.

[2] Wikepedia.org, “History of Baden-Württemberg,” rev. 23:24, 15 July 2020.

[3] St. Rose of Lima (Springfield, New Jersey) Catholic Church, Parish Register, Register of Baptism, Christopher Getter (1868); digital image FamilySearch.org (http://www.familysearch.org : accessed 25 July 2018). And one for his brother the following month.

[4] https://www.archion.de

[5] Wikipedia.org, “Sulzfeld (Baden),” rev. 22:10, 3 July 2020. You might note I use Wikipedia a lot. This is not something I would do in a scholarly format, but when I need to get to something in a quick and dirty manner, it is ideal. 

The Ravenburg Castle. Photo from the Burg-Restaurant Ravensburg website (https://www.burgrestaurant-ravensburg.de/de/ueber-uns : accessed 3 Aug 2020).

The Ravenburg Castle. Photo from the Burg-Restaurant Ravensburg website (https://www.burgrestaurant-ravensburg.de/de/ueber-uns : accessed 3 Aug 2020).

Week 29: Newsworthy #52 Ancestors

On March 4, 1879, my third great-grandfather, John Michael Rebholz, turned 100. His family and the town of Reading, Pennsylvania went all out to celebrate and thanks to two articles in the Reading Eagle, I learned about the day’s celebrations.[1] Already “famous” for being the oldest resident of Reading, a Pittsburgh paper wrote on his ninety-eighth birthday he was still “brisk and healthy” and had over one hundred great-grandchildren.[2]

The day started out with mass at 7:30 AM at St. Paul’s Catholic Church. Crowded with well-wishers, Michael did not attend for fear of catching a cold in the damp weather. Nevertheless, he is reported to have awakened at about six AM to pray from a book he had given his wife when they were married seventy-five years earlier. 

In the afternoon until late evening, several hundred relatives and friends attended his birthday party held at his son-in-law’s hotel, the Madison House. Those attending included Monsignor George Borneman, the rector of St. Paul’s, and incoming Reading mayor Henry Tyson and his wife. At 8:00, dinner was served in the large banquet room where six seatings were needed to feed all the attendees. At 10:00, the “Caecilia Saengerbund” entertained the assembly. A “saengerbund” is a German choral society (sänger – singer + bund – club).[3] The Caecilia Saengerbund was one of the largest and most influential of these groups back in the day.[4]

Growing up, I had heard stories about an ancestor whose hundredth birthday was celebrated by the town of Reading with a parade lead by John Philip Sousa. Grinning at another story with perhaps a little grain of truth. While I enjoyed reading about his birthday celebrations, none of those articles told me much about the man himself. However, when he died about a year later, the Reading Eagle published an extensive obituary on page one.[5]

The obit is chock-full of information which I assumed would help with my research. I verified that Michael was indeed born in the village of Ramberg in Bavaria.[6] The obit says he was one of nine children and that he and his wife had twelve. While I have no reason to dispute these numbers, I haven’t located them all (yet).[7] The paper noted that his wife did not emigrate to the U.S.  and died in 1849 which I found to be true.[8]

The obituary noted Michael’s long history as a butcher, a trade many of his sons and grandsons also followed and that he had a ninety-three-year-old brother living in New York.[9] It described Michael’s military service as a soldier who fought at the “Siege” of the French-held Fort Landau in 1793 where the French under Adam Phillippe, Comte d Custine, defeated the Prussians.[10]

I was so very excited to find all of this information about Michael: he lived to be almost 101, he was a soldier, he had all these kids, etc. I didn’t look too deeply into his life until I decided to write this blog. As anticipated, I see things a little differently now.

First of all, if Michael was born in 1779, he would have been fourteen at the Siege of Landau (1793), which I suppose could be true. But really?  Secondly, I couldn’t find that Custine was actually at the Siege of Landau. Thirdly, near as I can tell, Ramberg was not in Prussia. What gives? Was the paper wrong or was Michael telling a story?

You guessed it. Another tall-tale.[11]

The first record I found for Michael, the 1860 U.S. census, said he was seventy-five.[12] Hmm. Wouldn’t that mean he was born in 1785? I then found his baptismal record from 1786 where it noted he was an infant. And this week, I located his naturalization records and the manifest for the ship he arrived on. Guess what? They all show a 1786 birthdate.

Well rats! Just when you think you have this great story, it turns out to be pure invention. 

I wonder what Michael’s reaction was when he found out what was being cooked up for his “100th”? By then, did he believe his own story or did he figure it was too late to stop it so he might as well enjoy it?

Not to leave on a sour-note, here’s what the Philadelphia Herald had to say about his passing:

The Philadelphia Herald thinks that when John Michael Rebholz, an aged fellow citizen, died at Reading last Sunday, aged 101, he could not have imagined that he was going to be telegraphed all over the country and talked about in the newspapers. But his was the happy fate to say “beer” with his departing breath, and that thrilling utterance has already taken its place beside the “last words” that will live in history.[13]

I’ll drink to that.


[1] “The Centennarian’s Birthday,” Reading (Pennsylvania) Eagle, 4 March 1879, p. 1, col. 3. “The Centennarian Serenated,” Reading (Pennsylvania) Eagle, 5 March 1879, p. 1, col. 2.

[2] “The oldest man in Reading,” The Pittsburgh Commercial, 24 February 1876, p. 2, col. 4.

[3] Merriam-Webster Online Dictionary (http://www.merriam-webster.com : accessed 23 July 2020), “saengerbund.”

[4] “Much Trouble Ahead for German Singers,” The Brooklyn Daily Eagle, 4 September 1900, p. 16, col. 1.

[5] “Reading’s Centenarian Dead,” Reading (Pennsylvania) Eagle, 9 February 1880, p. 1, col 2.

[6] Church Register, Albersweiler, Rheinland-Pfalz, 1785-1790, p. 14, Joannes Michael Rebholz (1786); digital image, FamilySearch (https://www.familysearch.org : accessed 19 October 2018), FHL microfilm 247684, image 154 of 166.

[7] I found six of his siblings and ten of his children.

[8] Catholic Church, Ramberg, Bayern, Germany, deaths, 1835-1868, page 130, Catharina Knapp, 20 November 1849; digital image, FamilySearch (https://www.familysearch.org : accessed 19 October 2018), FHL microfilm 367395, image 80 of 532. Catherine died a year after Michael left for America. I wonder if she was too ill to make the trip and he went because so many of their children had already immigrated.

[9] Probably true. 1870 U.S. census, Kings County, New York, population schedule, Brooklyn, Ward 19, p. 370, dwelling 30, family 88, Louese (sic) Rebholtz; digital image, Ancestry  (http://www.ancestry.com : accessed 26 July 2020); citing National Archives microfilm publication M593, roll 959. 

[10] A distinguished general, Custine fought with the Americans at the Battle of Yorktown. He had many enemies in Paris and was convicted of treason and lost his head in the guillotine.

[11] I was explaining to my sister-in-law the other day that I have been keeping up with the #52 Ancestors in 52 Weeks even though lately it’s been a bit of a slog. One reason that I come back to write each week (or so) is that I get to do a deep-dive into a person or topic and the payoff is always worth it. This time is no exception.

[12] Oh, by the way, if you haven’t returned your census form yet, please do it NOW! You can fill it out online by going to www.2020census.gov. 1860 U.S. census, Berks County, Pennsylvania, population schedule, Reading, South Ward, p. 1199, dwelling 1194, family 1249, Michael Rebholtz; digital image, Ancestry (http://www.ancestry.com : accessed 26 July 2020); citing National Archives microfilm publication M653, roll not noted.

[13] “The Beer We Drink,” Williamsport (Pennsylvania) Sun Gazette, 13 February 1880, p. 2, col 3.

Since I don’t have a picture of Michael, this is a drawing of the packet ship Devonshire that he took from London to New York in November 1848. I’ve yet to figure out why he took that route, as most German immigrants traveled out of the port of Le H…

Since I don’t have a picture of Michael, this is a drawing of the packet ship Devonshire that he took from London to New York in November 1848. I’ve yet to figure out why he took that route, as most German immigrants traveled out of the port of Le Havre, France. This colored lithograph was drawn by Thomas Goldsworthy Dutton in June of 1848 and presented to the captain of the Devonshire, E.E. Morgan. The original lithograph can be found at the National Maritime Museum, Greenwich, London. Royal Museums Greenwich (https://collections.rmg.co.uk/collections/objects/140557.html : accessed 26 July 2020).

Week 28: Multiple #52Ancestors

One of my favorite family photos shows four generations in my husband’s family: his uncle, his grandmother, his great-grandmother, and his second great-grandmother. Multiple generations in one photograph is too special not to share along with a brief sketch of some of those pictured.

The youngest person in the picture is little Edward Lee Baty, born in February of 1919 while his father served in the U.S. Army.[1] The oldest in the picture is Catherine (aka Kate) Fitzgibbon, Eddie’s great-grandmother on his mother’s side, born in 1847. Since Kate died in 1927 and Eddie looks to be about two, I would date this picture from 1921-22.

The other women in the picture are Kate’s daughter, Mary Quinlan (standing) and Mary’s daughter (Eddie’s mom), Kathryn Ann McCormick (on right). I am sure you’ve noticed all of the Irish names. Indeed, half of Eddie’s great-grandparents were Irish born. At that time of this photo, all three of the women’s families lived in Parsons, Kansas, in homes an eight- to five-minute walk from each other. 

So how did all those Irish people wind up in South-East Kansas? 

Starting with the oldest in the picture (seated on the left), Kate Fitzgibbon was born November 10, 1847 in Fall River, Massachusetts to John and Mary (Finn) Fitzgibbon.[2] John and Mary were born in Ireland: John in County Clare and Mary in County Cork.[3] I have not discovered where and how they met nor have I found evidence of their marriage. Mary had a son from a previous marriage who immigrated with her to New York in 1834.[4] That early of an immigration date means she was not a victim of the Great Famine. What drove her to emigrate without her husband and two other sons is still a mystery.[5] John immigrated to Boston in 1842 and settled in Fall River.[6] That date of emigration is also a bit early to be blamed on the Great Famine. However, a huge increase in the Irish population from 1801 to 1841 (50%) put great stress on the poor and densely populated western counties including Clare.[7] Further, in 1839 and again in 1842 the west of Ireland experienced severe food shortages that the British government was ill-equipped to handle. As an example, in 1842 there was only one work house for the three hardest hit counties, Clare, Kerry, and Mayo.[8] It is no wonder John left when he did. 

John and Mary lived in Fall River for about ten years where John was a “laborer” and they had six children.[9] The family then moved to Marshall county, Illinois where they had two more children and John became a farmer, owning about 150 acres of land.[10] It is in Illinois where John and Mary’s second child, Mary, met and married John Quinlan an Irish immigrant from County Cork. 

 Born in Kilworth, County Clare in 1835, John Quinlan survived most of the famine with his mother, aunt, sister, and other relatives.[11] His father had died by 1851 and his brothers, Michael and Daniel, had immigrated to Boston in 1849.[12] Both brothers settled in Plymouth county, Massachusetts, where they worked as bootmakers.[13] The family story is that John immigrated to New Orleans in about 1857 and never made his way to his brothers in Boston. It is not known if John and his brothers ever reunited, but his daughter appears to have visited some of Michael and Daniel’s descendants in 1910. 

 John settled in Illinois and served for a brief time in the 104th Illinois Infantry during the Civil War.[14] Discharged in January of 1863 because of a disability, he and Kate Fitzgibbon married the following year.[15] By 1880, the family had moved to Labette county in south-east Kansas.[16] A farmer for a time, John also worked for the railroad in Parsons. I’ve mentioned Kate and John’s large family before – they had thirteen children, the oldest of which was Mary, the woman standing in the picture. 

 Mary married Edward McCormick, another first-generation American in Parsons on August 21, 1889.[17] Ed’s parents Richard and Bridget (Conroy) immigrated from County Mayo, although from different parts and they likely met in Illinois where they married.[18] This family also made their way from Illinois to Parsons, which is where Edward and Mary met and married. The youngest woman seated in the picture is their eldest daughter, Kathryn who met and married Lee Baty in Parsons.[19] The toddler Eddie was the oldest of their four children. 

 My husband is Kathryn’s grandson and his Ancestry.com DNA “Ethnicity Estimate” of 50% Ireland/Scotland is no lie. 


[1] Kansas State Board of Health, Division of Vital Statistics, certificate of birth no. 250 2162, Edward Lee Baty (1919), Office of Vital Statistics, Topeka.

[2] Kansas State Board of Health, Division of Vital Statistics, death certificate no. 250 3101, Kate Quinlan (1927); Office of Vital Statistics, Topeka. This is some question as to Mary’s maiden name. This certificate says “Finucane” but some records show it was likely Finn.

[3] John Fitz-Gibbons petition for naturalization (6 November 1848), file no. 379A, Police Court, New Bedford, Bristol, Massachusetts; digital image, “Massachusetts, State and Federal Naturalization Records, 1798-1950,” Ancestry (http://www.ancestry.com : accessed 15 July 2020). Illinois State Board of Health, physician's certificate of death no. 3563, Mary Fitzgibbons (1890); Cook County Clerk, Bureau of Vital Records, Genealogy Unit, Chicago. 

[4] Manifest, S.S. William Glen Anderson, 31 May 1834, third page, 147 and 148, Mary and Dennis Haggerty, ages 25 and 0; digital image, “New York, Passenger and Crew Lists (including Castle Garden and Ellis Island), 1820-1957,” Ancestry (http://www.ancestry.com : accessed 15 July 2020).

[5] I suspect they died in Ireland, but to say so would be pure speculation. I think this will be an interesting story if I can dig it up.

[6] John Fitz-Gibbon petition for naturalization (1848), file no. 379A.  

[7] Christine Kinealy, “The Rags and Wretched Cabins of Ireland 1845,” This Great Calamity: The Irish Famine 1845-52 (Boulder, Col.: Roberts Rinehart Publishers, 1995), 9.

[8] Ibid, 29.

[9] 1850 U.S. census, Bristol County, Massachusetts, population schedule, Fall River, p. 10B, dwelling 1039, family 1760, John Fitzgibbon; digital image, Ancestry (http://www.ancestry.com : accessed 15 July 2020); citing National Archives microfilm publication M432, roll 308. 1860 U.S. census, Marshall County, Illinois, population schedule, Lacon, p. 71, dwelling 548, family 526, John Fitzgibbon; digital image, Ancestry (http://www.ancestry.com : accessed 15 July 2020); citing National Archives microfilm publication M653, roll not noted.

[10] 1880 U.S. census, Marshal County, Illinois, agricultural schedule, Richland, p. 13. John Fitzgibbon; digital image, Ancestry (http://www.ancestry.com : accessed 15 July 2020.

[11] Josephine Masterson, County Cork, A Collection of 1851 Census Records (Baltimore, Maryland: Genealogical Publishing Co., Inc., 1994), 30.

[12] Manifest, S.S. Bark Regulus, 15 June 1849, third page, Daniel and Mike Quinlan, ages 15 and 19; digital image, “Massachusetts, Passenger and Crew Lists, 1820-1963,” Ancestry (http://www.ancestry.com : accessed 15 July 2020).

[13] 1865 Massachusetts state census, Plymouth County, population schedule, Abington Center Ward, [no page no. visible], dwelling 261, family 318, Michael Quinlan and Daniel Quinlan; digital image, “Massachusetts, State Census, 1865,” Ancestry (http://www.ancestry.com : accessed 15 July 2020).

[14] Report of the Adjutant General of the State of Illinois, vol. 5 (Springfield, Illinois: Phillips Bros., 1901), 658; digital image, Internet Archive (https://archive.org/details/reportofadjutant05illi1 : accessed 15 July 2020).

[15] Ibid. Illinois, Marshall County, marriage license, John Quinlan-Kate Fitzibbons (1864); copy obtained from Illinois Regional Archives Depository (IRAD), Illinois State University, Normal, Illinois.

[16] 1880 U.S. census, Labette County, Kansas, population schedule, Walton township, p. 10B, dwelling 79, family 81, John Quinlan; digital image, Ancestry(http://www.ancestry.com : accessed 15 July 2020); citing National Archives microfilm publication T9, roll 385.

[17] Probate Office, Labette County, Kansas, Marriage License, Edward McCormick-Mary Quinlan (1889), p. 174; digital image, “Kansas, County Marriage Records, 1811-1911,” Ancestry (http://www.ancestry.com : accessed 15 July 2020).

[18] Will County, Illinois marriage license, no. 01650, Richard McCormick-Bridget Conroy (1852); copy obtained from Illinois Regional Archives Depository (IRAD), Illinois State University, Normal, Illinois.

[19] Montgomery County, Illinois Marriage license, no. 6670, Lee Baty-Kathryn Ann McCormick (1918); Kansas Division of Vital Statistics, Topeka.

From left to right: Catherine (Fitzgibbon) Quinlan (1847-1927); Edward Lee Baty (1919-2003); Mary (Quinlan) McCormick (1866-1936); and, Kathryn Ann (McCormick) Baty (1892-1982).

From left to right: Catherine (Fitzgibbon) Quinlan (1847-1927); Edward Lee Baty (1919-2003); Mary (Quinlan) McCormick (1866-1936); and, Kathryn Ann (McCormick) Baty (1892-1982).

Week 27: Solo #52Ancestors

My husband and I have one child – a wonderful, caring, and generous son. Having one child isn’t all that unusual these days, but it was for our ancestors. My tree has many families with nine or more children. Even as recent at the 1960’s only children were unusual. Heck, I grew up in a family of five children and we were one of the smaller in our community.

For the longest time, I thought that my second great-grandfather might have been an only child. But that was only because I hadn’t spent enough time researching English church records. Parish registers are chock-full of good information and if you have the patience to figure out which churches your ancestors might have gone to the pay-off can be immense. It took me a while to get my mind wrapped around the differences between the civil jurisdictions and the ecclesiastical jurisdictions. It is made a tad more difficult because there can be a number of churches and chapelries in each parish and if your family was like mine, they didn’t stick to one place for their religious ceremonies. As an example, when my second great-grandfather, George Spencer, married Jane Buckley in 1844 the ceremony took place at St. Mary the Virgin in Bury, Lancashire.[1] However, when their son was baptized they went to the Chapelry in Holcombe, one of seven chapelries they could have chosen.[2]

Without getting too deep in the weeds, suffice it to say that the FamilySearch Wiki is your friend when trying to sort out what ecclesiastical jurisdictions you might need to search. For those of us with Lancashire ancestors, OnLine Parish Clerks database is a great free resource.[3]

The parish records told me that George’s father was a grocer and, sadly, I let it led me down the wrong path for a short while since I kept looking for siblings in the baptismal records whose father was a grocer. I soon found out that he wasn’t always a grocer. It wasn’t until later in his life that he went into the grocery business. From at least 1805 to 1821, he worked as a “calico printer.”

Now here’s something I bet you didn’t know: from 1721 to 1774, it was illegal to wear calico in England.[4] At the behest of the woolen and silk manufacturers, parliament prohibited the wearing of cotton cloth and then later the use of cotton for any purpose. One of the primary centers for calico printing at that time in England was London which saw riots over this law to the extent that some who wore calico had their clothing torn to pieces.[5] Yikes! By the time calico printing had fully reestablished in England, the manufacturing hub had migrated to Lancashire, where George Spencer plied that trade until he became a grocer.[6]

So back to those great English parish records. When I finally find George the calico printer, I track back to his first marriage, the children with that wife and then his second marriage and the children with that wife, include those from her first marriage. All in all, my third great-grandfather had twelve children and stepchildren. No wonder he quit the calico printing work (likely for someone else) and went into his own grocery business.[7] And my second great-grandfather? An only child no more.

 

 


[1] St. Mary, Bury, Lancashire, England, marriages, 1844-1845, page 123, Spencer-Buckley, 11 November 1844; digital image, “Manchester, England, Church of England Marriages and Banns, 1754-1930,”Ancestry (http://www.ancestry.com : accessed 10 July 2020); citing Anglican Parish Registers, Manchester Libraries, Information and Archives, Manchester, England. 

[2] Bishop’s Transcript, Holcombe, baptisms, 1840-1849, page 168 Edward Spencer, 23 March 1845; digital image, “Lancashire, England, Church of England Births and Baptisms, 1813-1911,” Ancestry (http://www.ancestry.com : accessed 10 July 2020); citing Lancashire Anglican Parish Registers, Preston, England. The four-month span between George and Jane’s marriage and the birth of their son is not lost on me.

[3] http://www.lan-opc.org.uk/indexp.html

[4] Parkunnel J. Thomas, “The Beginnings of Calico-Printing in England,” The English Historical Review 39 (1924): 201-217, specifically, 214; digital images Google Books (http://books.Google.com : accessed 9 July 2020).

[5] Ibid.

[6] G.N. Wright, M.A., Lancashire: its History, Legends, and Manufactures (London: Fisher, Son, & Co., 1841), 23; digital images Google Books (http://books.Google.com : accessed 9 July 2020).

[7] You can read more about George the grocer in 2019 Week 45: “Rich Man” of this blog.

“Calico printing” in Lancashire.  Drawn by T. Allom, engraved by J. Carter (London) Fisher, Son & Co., 1835; digital image, G.N. Wright, M.A., Lancashire: its History, Legends, and Manufactures (London: Fisher, Son, & Co., 1841), 2…

“Calico printing” in Lancashire. Drawn by T. Allom, engraved by J. Carter (London) Fisher, Son & Co., 1835; digital image, G.N. Wright, M.A., Lancashire: its History, Legends, and Manufactures (London: Fisher, Son, & Co., 1841), 21; digital images Google Books (http://books.Google.com : accessed 9 July 2020).

Textile Sample, Bury, Lancashire, 1780; digital image, The Metropolitan Museum of Art (https://www.metmuseum.org/art/collection/search/212240?exhibitionId=%7B063A1AA2-5A4E-439A-A332-046E00E8BD73%7D&oid=212240&pg=6&rpp=20&pos=1&ft…

Textile Sample, Bury, Lancashire, 1780; digital image, The Metropolitan Museum of Art (https://www.metmuseum.org/art/collection/search/212240?exhibitionId=%7B063A1AA2-5A4E-439A-A332-046E00E8BD73%7D&oid=212240&pg=6&rpp=20&pos=1&ft=%2A&img=2 : accessed 12 July 2020).

Week 26: Middle #52Ancestors

Middle seat?

 The Middle? [by Zedd – shout-out to CJB]

 Middle school?

 Middle child? [The well-adjusted kind.]

 Middle Earth? [You know who you are.]

 Lots of options on this week’s prompt from our fearless leader, Amy Johnson Crow.

 How about “middle name”?

 It has endlessly bugged my husband’s cousin that their grandfather does not appear to have a middle name. Of the numerous records related to Lee Baty, none of them show a middle name. His siblings have a middle name but not him. While this invites speculation, it is likely we will never know the answer. Insert sad face.

 I like middle names immensely. They can be a key to finding the maiden name of an ancestor. 

 I’ve noted before how hard it is to find women in the records after they marry. However, in my family tree – and I am sure this is nearly universal – I have many ancestors whose middle name (and sometimes first name) is the mother’s family name.

A few examples:

  • 5th great-grandfather Henry Lowe’s middle name “Stonestreet” – his mother’s maiden name.

  • The same 5th great-grandfather’s son John’s middle name “Tolson” – his grandmother’s adopted surname.

  • 4th great-grandparents Thomas and Elizabeth Batson’s fifth son’s middle “Hatton” – his grandmother’s maiden name.

  • 4th great-grandparents James and Elizabeth Moore’s first child’s middle name “Hightower” – his mother’s maiden name.

 I have lots of examples, but I will stop here as I am sure you get the point.

 No mistake, when you find this, it is not conclusive proof of a family connection but another helpful piece in the puzzle.

It also reminds me of a funny story. 

 Growing up, I’d been told that after her husband’s death my grandmother changed my dad’s name from Anthony to Anson because Anthony was “too Italian.” No surprise since she’s also the only one I remember ever using the n-word. 

Fast-forward to my genealogy work many years later and, of course, I learn that story only has a little bit of truth to it.

My dad’s father was the actually the only one in the family with “Anthony” as a first name, although his birth return would not tell you that. It took a little sleuthing to find it, but the birth return for him says his first name is “Frederick.”[1] [A “birth return” is similar to a birth certificate – the medical attendant fills it out reporting the birth to the local authority – in this case, the County of New York.] Since I know from other documents that Anthony was born on October 6, 1883, I know this is his return and not that of a brother.[2] When baptized fifteen days later, his name was “Antonius,” Latin for Anthony. Somewhere along the way he adopted “Joseph” for a middle name (his father’s first name). Things were a little more loosie-goosie back then, I guess.

My dad was born Anson Anthony Glacy and by the time he enlisted in the military for World War II, his name was Anson Joseph Glacy. So cool, the story sort of checks out.

Not so fast.

As a collector of family memorabilia, I have a copy of my parents wedding invitation from 1953 where Mr. and Mrs. Charles Peter Maier request the honour of your presence at the marriage of their daughter Mary Regina to Mr. Anson Jordan Glacy.

Say what? Jordan? Where did that come from? 

Fast-forward again. I keep plugging along and lo and behold I find that my dad’s great-grandmother was Mary Jordan. Now, my grandmother likely knew her grandmother since they lived near each other and my grandmother was thirty-one when Mary died. Could that be where it came from? I asked my aunt about that and she told me that her brother did go by the name of “Jordy” but she had no memory of why he went by Jordan. 

My aunt also told me the real story behind why my dad’s middle name was changed. Apparently, when he was in high school, he used “J” for his middle initial (presumably for “Jordan”). When he graduated, the good fathers at Seton Hall Prep must have decided that the “J” stood for Joseph and his diploma said that. However, when he went to enlist in the Navy, his birth certificate did not match his diploma. Instead of asking for a new diploma, my grandmother did the only reasonable thing – she had his name legally changed.[3] When I say “reasonable,” I don’t mean that. 

Bye-bye Anthony, hello Joseph. One family story corrected and one maiden name discovered. 

 

 


[1] New York, New York County, New York City, Birth Return no. 378547, Frederick Glacy, 6 Oct. 1883.

[2] For example: “United States, World War I Draft Registration Cards, 1917-1918,” images, Ancestry (http://www.ancestry.com : accessed 4 July 2020), card for Anthony Joseph Glacy, serial no. not legible, Local Board 5, Essex County, New Jersey; original data United States, Selective Service System, World War I Selective Service System Draft Registration Cards, 1917-1918, microfilm publication M1509 (Washington, D.C. : National Archives and Records Administration), roll 1712104. I have not found that he was a twin.

[3] New Jersey, Department of Health and Senior Services, Bureau of Vital Statistics, Request for correction to be made to original certificate, Anson Anthony Glacy to Anson Joseph Glacy, 24 July 1942, Trenton, NJ.

Chief Specialist (A) V6, USNR, Anson Joseph Glacy, Sr.

Chief Specialist (A) V6, USNR, Anson Joseph Glacy, Sr.

Christopher George Goetter and Mary Jordan. Date unknown. Dog unknown.

Christopher George Goetter and Mary Jordan. Date unknown. Dog unknown.

Week 25: Unexpected #52Ancestors

When I started down the family history road with my husband’s paternal line, I dove into it with minimal background information and family legends, such as:

·      Baty was originally spelled Beatty.

·      Beatty’s were originally Scottish, from a “Border Reivers” clan.          

·      The Beattys came from Scotland to northern-Ireland and then settled in the U.S.

·      The family is descendant from Colonel William Ashfordby Beatty, Jr, a Revolutionary War hero.

 There are lots of famous Beattys, including Warren, Ned, Ryan, and others. There are towns named Beatty in Nevada, Ohio, and Oregon.[1] I’ve read in several places that Beatty may have been derived from Bartholomew. A Baty cousin told me he had contacted relatives in Scotland and had been invited to see the ancestral home. 

 Okay, all well and good and I am on my merry way.

 As I’ve previously mentioned, I know next to nothing about DNA.  However, I do know that if you want to trace a paternal line, you need to take a Y-DNA test. So, back in 2011, I sent away for a Y-DNA test for my husband from FamilyTreeDNA, the only Y-DNA public testing company. I ordered a test that analyzed 37 markers on the Y-chromosome and got back a couple of Baty matches, but also some Owens and Hines. I immediately added Bruce to the Beatty Y-chromosome project at FTDNA. Currently, the project has over 600 men with the Beatty surname, including variants, working to connect lineages via DNA to supplement traditional research. The guys that run the group are really great.

 Okay, la de da. All good.

 For a reason I cannot remember now, in 2015, I decided to upgrade Bruce’s DNA analysis to what was called the Big Y-500 and that’s when the “trouble” started.[2] I got a message from one of the Beatty administrators who said (paraphrasing here) “Bruce can stay in the Beatty project because of his last name, but he really belongs in the ‘Clan Colla 425 null’ project.” So, like a good girl, I add Bruce to the Clan Colla project and if I was barely treading water before, I am truly drowning now. Since I can’t comprehend 90% of any of this you will be (mercifully) spared any detail analysis. What I found out in regard to the four bullet points above:

·      No.

·      No.

·      No.

·      No.

 Well that was unexpected.

 The first thing I learn about the “Clan Colla 425 null” project is that it is named thus because all of the men in this project have a 0 (“null”) for the 425 STR marker. Quick DNA lesson: a STR is a “short tandem repeat” which are very short regions located along the Y chromosome. “Each is made up of multiple copies of a short sequence of nucleotide bases that repeat a variable number of times.”[3] Each STR marker has a different name; in this case DYS425.[4] There are three other STR markers that define the Clan Colla DNA and here are over 600 men in the FTDNA Clan Colla project who have these markers and other distinguishing mutations, including Bruce. Because the Y-chromosome does not undergo extensive recombination as it is passed down to the next generation, it is particularly useful in determining the paternal line. A value of “0” for any marker is infrequent.

 All of the men in this project descended from three warlike brothers known as the Three Collas who lived in the early part of the 4th century in a part of Ireland called Airgíalla (in Ulster).[5] Where these brothers came from is still up for debate. One view is that they were Roman-trained mercenaries from Colchester in Essex. Another theory is that they migrated from the west of Scotland.[6] The discussion among the academics and researchers is fascinating, but inconclusive. And while interesting, none of it is helpful for my research as the Baty/Beatty surname is not yet traditionally associated with the Three Collas. 

 What do I do with this unexpected turn of events?  

 David Baty is Bruce’s third great-grandfather and the last known ancestor on his paternal line. A big bright brick wall. Over many years, I’ve used lots of strategies to try and find his origins. The earliest evidence I have for his existence is the marriage bond between him and Samuel Pickerill dated May 9, 1808, in Mason County, Kentucky.[7] I’ve nothing on his parents, siblings, cousins or where he was born.

 Armed with this DNA analysis, this is my current working theory:

 David’s father was not a Baty/Beatty. 

One of Bruce’s paternal ancestors is related to 

·      Thomas Hines from Ireland;

·      Hugh Owens from Ireland; and/or

·      Eugene J. Owen from Ireland and Franklin County, PA.

 My next step will be to build out trees for all these men and see where/if David intersects. Wish me luck!

 


[1] Wikipedia.org, “Beatty,” rev. 10:52, 3 June 2020.

[2] FTDNA does a “Big Y-700” now where they analyze over 200,000 SNPs and up to 700 STRs.

[3] Blaine T. Bettinger and Debbie Parker Wayne, “Chapter 3: Genealogical Applications for Y-DNA,” Genetic Genealogy in Practice (Arlington, Virginia: National Genealogical Society, 2016), 26.

[4] D=DNA, Y=Y chromosome, S=segment. Ibid.

[5] “Background - Who Were the Three Collas?” Clan Colla 425 null, (https://www.familytreedna.com/groups/clancolla-42-5null/about/background : accessed 2 July 2020). 

[6] “Origin of the Three Collas - Patrick McMahon Email of May 17, 2018,” Z3000 DNA of the Three Collas(http://www.peterspioneers.com/colla.htm#origin : accessed 2 July 2020).

[7] Mason County, Kentucky, Clerk of the Court, “Loose bonds 1806-1819,” David Beatty-Emlou Pickerrell, 9 May 1808; “Kentucky, County Marriages, 1797-1954,” database with images, FamilySearch (https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:3QSQ-G9S7-9CRV?cc=1804888&wc=QD3Q-4X8%3A1300412311 : accessed 4 December 2017), FHL microfilm 5,552,766, image 81 of 569.

 

SNP Tracker for Bruce’s terminal SNP. Tracking Back (http://scaledinnovation.com/gg/gg.html?nm=tools)

SNP Tracker for Bruce’s terminal SNP. Tracking Back (http://scaledinnovation.com/gg/gg.html?nm=tools)

We have never been to Northern Ireland, but here is a lovely shot of the Killary Fjord in Connemara.

We have never been to Northern Ireland, but here is a lovely shot of the Killary Fjord in Connemara.

Week 24: Handed Down #52Ancestors

As my regular readers know, I am a family memento hoarder.[1] I took anything and everything my grandmothers had (which no one else wanted back in the day) and stored them away for safe-keeping. One of those items was a letter written in German from Charles Preiss to his brother-in-law and sister on 9 June 1862. When I received the letter, I had no idea who Charles was, but since the letter was written during the Civil War from a camp near Richmond, Virginia, I thought it “so cool” (the extent of my teenage thinking). My Nana who gave me the letter passed away in 1975, so I had it for over forty years before I decided to delve into the who, what, when, where, and how of this letter. 

First things first: there is no Charles Preiss in my family tree nor anyone with that last name so who the heck was he? Back in the 1970’s there was no “easy” way to figure this out (even if I had wanted to then or had the time). As more and more records have become digitized and accessible, researching Charles became vastly more do-able. My initial step was to get the letter translated. Thank goodness for the marvelous volunteers at the old Facebook group “Genealogy Translations.” Sadly, that particular group no longer exists, but a couple of years ago I posted the letter and a kind volunteer translated it. The letter tells about the battle that had just concluded but mentions little else about his family other than the fact that his parents were moving.[2] It doesn’t even name the recipients of the letter, so no clues there. 

 My next step was to build a family tree for Charles on Ancestry.com. While I am not fully satisfied with the tree, I have enough to answer some of the questions I have about Charles.

 Charles was one of five children born to August Preiss and Julia Leicing in Prussia. The family emigrated to the United States likely around 1852-1860, although I suspect not all of them came at the same time. The family appears to have settled in New York City and vicinity. On August 28, 1861 at New Dorp, Staten Island, twenty-year-old Charles enlisted in Company H of the 55th Regiment of the New York State Militia for a three-year term of service.[3] The 55th Regiment was under the command of Colonel Baron Philippe Regis de Trobiand.[4] De Trobiand deserves a quick mention here. He was a French aristocrat, lawyer, poet, and novelist who emigrated to New York on a dare.[5] His father had been a general in Napoleon Bonaparte’s army and de Trobiand achieved the rank of brigadier general in the U.S. He married the heiress of a prominent New York banker and retired to the French Quarter of New Orleans.[6]

 Anyway, the 55th was called “La Fayette’s Guard,” because it allegedly was composed of mostly of men with French origins.[7]However, all but one of the men who enlisted in Company H on Staten Island appear to have German names. 

 The 55th left New York on August 31 for Maryland where it became a part of Buell’s Division, Army of the Potomac. In March of 1862, the 55th joined McClellan’s army and participated in the siege of Yorktown and the battle of Williamsburg.[8]They then took part in the Battle of Seven Pines, also known as the Battle of Fair Oaks (six-miles from Richmond) which took place on May 31 and June 1, 1862.[9] This was the largest battle in the “Eastern Theater” up to that time, although the result was inconclusive. The most historically significant event during the battle was the injury sustained by Confederate General Joseph E. Johnston which lead to the appointment of Robert E. Lee as commander of the Army of Northern Virginia.[10] Because of Lee’s aggressiveness and McClellan’s incompetence, Lee drove the Union army away from Richmond and nearly to Washington, D.C., the capital of the Union forces. It would take the Union army two years to get that close to Richmond again.[11]

 Charles’ letter was addressed to his brother-in-law and sister and is dated a week after the Battle of Fair Oaks In it, he recounts his experiences during the battle. He is supremely proud of the regiment claiming they got “fame and congratulations by the Generals, not often has such a small regiment has such great success.”[12] He acknowledges that it was a “bloodbath” for both sides and says it was the first time that they used their “horrendous bayonets.” He goes on:

 But the enemy was too strong for us and one brigade after another was sent against them. Finally, we had to go back, because it was already dark and so we lost the first day. And the fine rebels got the honor to sleep in our camp under our Blankets and eat our crackers, but they hadn’t this fun for long, because we got the whole day reinforcement and attacked them in daybreak. And we drift them before us like a bunch of sheep under horrible loss and they left their wounded behind. By the way, dear brother-in-law! It were (sic) two shockingly day and the death laid in heaps around and all houses were full with wounded. Our losses were huge, but the loses of the Rebels must have been more than ours. Thanks God I escaped without a harm but I lost many of my best comrades….

 Charles estimated that the regiment lost about 120 men, which is pretty close to the official figure of 103.[13] While he didn’t mention this in his letter, he was promoted from Private to Sergeant after the first day of battle.[14] Charles speculates (hopefully?) that their regiment is too small for another battle, but the 55th goes on to fight in the Seven Days’ Battles in June and July of 1862 and in Fredericksburg, December 11 to 15, 1862. 

 On 21 December 1862, command of the 55th was transferred to the 38th New York Infantry and all the soldiers who had not completed their term were now part of the 38th. By that time, Charles was a First Sergeant, having been promoted again in October of 1862.[15] If Charles thought he’d seen the worst of the fighting he was wrong.

 The 38th (also called the “Second Scott’s Lifeguard”) was another New York City Regiment and fought at the same battles as the 55th under the command of Col. J. H. Hobart Ward.[16] Ward was a career army soldier from a family of soldiers; his grandfather fought in the Revolutionary War and his father fought in the War of 1812.[17] Wounded several times during the war, he rose to the rank of general. After the war, he served as a clerk for the Superior Court of New York City and died after having been struck by a train when he was eighty.[18]

 Charles was with the 38th for about six months and fought with the company at Chancellorsville in April and May of 1863. Despite being twice the size of the Confederate forces, the Union lost in a stunning Confederate victory known as Lee’s “perfect battle.”[19] The fighting on May 3rd was the second bloodiest day of the Civil war causing heavy losses on both sides – about 25,000 killed or wounded.[20] Charles survived that battle and shortly thereafter was transferred to Company A of the 40th Infantry Regiment, another New York regiment, aka Mozart Regiment and United States Constitution Guard.[21]

 Immediately after Charles joined the 40th, it marched to Gettysburg, Pennsylvania. A turning-point in the war, the Battle of Gettysburg involved the largest number of casualties of the entire war, including Charles who was injured on the first day of the battle.[22] He was discharged from service due to disability six months later in New York City.[23] While I understand he received a pension, I don’t have his file, so don’t know the extent of his injuries, but they must have been pretty severe. I also don’t know of any medals he received for his service; the Purple Heart was not awarded until after World War I.[24]

 After the war, Charles married Caroline Marie Dorothy Schaal, another German immigrant.[25] They settled Kleindeutchland, or “Little Germany” where Charles ran a saloon, one on East 4th Street and then one on First Avenue.[26] Charles and Caroline had four children, but life was not kind to Charles or Caroline. As near as I can tell, all of their children died well before reaching their majority. And in February of 1880, Charles was adjudged a “lunatic.”[27] From what I can piece together, Charles received a severe head wound at Gettysburg which made him unstable and at one point at dinner, he went after his wife with a carving knife.[28] It is interesting to me that as a part of the 1880 U.S. census, there was a separate schedule for “Defective, Dependent, and Delinquent Classes.” This schedule shows Charles had been committed to the Bloomingdale Insane Asylum and that his dementia first came on when he was twenty-four, i.e. about the time of his injury at Gettysburg.[29] Charles lived at the asylum for almost twenty years and died there in April of 1899.[30] Caroline died less than a year later on January 16, 1900.[31]

 A sad ending to the story of a brave soldier.

 But wait, how does Charles letter get to my Nana who was born in New Jersey twenty-six years after the end of the Civil War? 

 The sad ending of Charles was made more depressing when I discovered a lawsuit was filed four months after Caroline’s death disputing which descendants were entitled to their house on East 30th St. in New York City.[32]  I mentioned that none of their children survived them, so who were these heirs? Turns out Charles’ sisters thought that Caroline had mismanaged Charles’ money and business before he died and that even though she died after Charles, none of her heirs should inherit the house. The Complaint filed by the sisters had to name everyone who might have a claim on this estate including his sisters and the grandchildren of his deceased brother and sister. So, while this is all very sad, having all those names and relationships was a boon to my research.

 The letter in question was addressed to Charles’ “dear brother-in-law and sister,” Since I now know that Charles had three sisters: Caroline, Julia, and Theresa I eliminate them one by one until I determine that the recipients were William and Julia (Preiss) Brockman. 

 Just like her siblings, Julia married a German immigrant, Albert F. W. (William) Brockmann.[33] While they were married in Manhattan, New York, they lived in Newark, New Jersey where William was a sewing machine agent and machinist.[34] The city directories for Newark show that from about 1877 to 1900, they lived in an apartment building at 48 Tichenor St. in Newark.[35] Hmmm, the name of that street sounded so very familiar to me. Sure enough, at the same time, my Nana and her parents lived on Tichenor and a couple of other apartments about two blocks away.[36] In fact, my Nana’s family moved to that same apartment building in 1908 although the Brockmann’s had left by then.

 My great-grandparents were of English and Irish descent and the Brockmanns were German. My great-grandparents had three children but the Brockmanns had none. My family was Catholic and although I don’t know what faith the Brockmanns practiced, even if it was Catholic they likely would have gone to different churches.[37] I can only imagine that as neighbors (and maybe friends) my great-grandfather may have shared his stories of the Civil War with William and/or Julia and maybe that is what lead them to give him this letter? It’s the only logical conclusion I can come to. 

 An informal poll for my readers: Should I offer this letter to Preiss ancestors I have located on Ancestry.com?

 

[1] And you know who you are, SJ.

[2] More about the battle follows.

[3] “Muster-In Roll of Captain –‘s Company (H,) in the 55th Regiment,” A Record of the Commissioned Officers, Non-Commissioned Officers and Privates, of the Regiments Which Were Organized in the State of New York and Called Into the Service of the United States to Assist in Suppressing the Rebellion, vol. II (Albany, New York: Comstock & Cassidy,1864), ; digital image, Fold3 (https://www.fold3.com/image/312101147/?terms=Preiss&xid=1945 :accessed 18 June 2020).

[4] “55th Infantry Regiment,” “Unit History Project,” New York State Military History Museum(https://dmna.ny.gov/historic/reghist/civil/infantry/55thInf/55thInfMain.htm : accessed 18 June 2020).

[5] Wikipedia.org, “Regis DeTrobiand,” rev. 22:02, 27 March 2020.

[6] Ibid. Quite the guy. Some day I’ll read this: Marie Caroline Post, Régis de Trobriand, The Life and Mémoirs of Comte Régis de Trobriand: Major-general in the Army of the United States (New York: E. P. Dutton & Company, 1910).

[7] “55th Infantry Regiment,” “Unit History Project,” New York State Military History Museum.

[8] Ibid.

[9] Wikipedia.org, “Battle of Seven Pines,” rev. 00:08, 30 May 2020.

[10] Ibid.

[11] Ibid.

[12] Charles Preiss to unknown, 9 June 1862; privately held by author, Overland Park, Kansas.

[13] Frederick Phisterer, New York in the War of the Rebellion, 3rd ed. (Albany, NY: J.B. Lyon Co., 1912).

[14] “Charles Priss,” “Fifty-Fifth Infantry,” Annual Report of the Adjutant-General of the State of New York, Serial No. 25 (Albany, NY: James B. Lyon, 1901), 948; digital image, Google Books (http://www.googlebooks.com : accessed 18 June 2020). 

[15] Ibid.

[16] “Thirty-Eighth Regiment of Infantry, Second Scott’s Life Guard,” Frederick Phisterer, New York in the War of the Rebellion, 2nd ed. (Albany, NY: Weed Parsons and Co., 1890), 401-2; digital image, Google Books (http://www.googlebooks.com : accessed 18 June 2020). 

[17] Wikipedia.org, “J.H. Hobart Ward,” rev. 02:47, 26 June 2019.

[18] Ibid.

[19] Wikipedia.org, “Battle of Chancellorsville,” rev. 01:34, 30 May 2020.

[20] Ibid.

[21] “40th Infantry Regiment,” “Unit History Project,” New York State Military History Museum.

[22] Wikipedia.org, “Battle of Gettysburg,” rev. 18:54, 21 June 2020. 

[23] “Charles Priss,” “Fortieth Infantry,” Annual Report of the Adjutant-General of the State of New York (Albany, NY: James B. Lyon, 1901), 574; digital image, Google Books (http://www.googlebooks.com : accessed 18 June 2020). 

[24] Wikipedia.org, “Purple Heart,” rev. 08:26, 16 May 2020.

[25] New York, Kings Co., Brooklyn, marriage certificate, Preiss-Schaal, 7 July 1867; “New York, New York City Marriage Records, 1829-1940,” FamilySearch, FHL microfilm 1,543,713.

[26] Goulding’s Business Directory of New York (New York: L.G. Goulding, Pub., 1871), 293; also subsequent years by the same title: (1872), 322, (1877) 201; digital images, “U.S. City Directories, 1822-1995,” Ancestry, (http://www.Ancestry.com : accessed 20 June 2020).  Trow’s New York City Directory (New York: Trow City Directory Co., 1878), 1136; also subsequent year by the same title: (1879), 1174; digital images, “U.S. City Directories, 1822-1995,” Ancestry, (http://www.Ancestry.com : accessed 20 June 2020).  

[27] Marcus T. Hun, Reporter, Reports of Cases Heard and Determined in the Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York, (Albany, NY: J.B. Lyon Co., 1902), 70:34, Storm, et al. v. McGrover, et al.; digital images, Google Books (http://www.googlebooks.com : accessed 18 June 2020).

[28] Papers on Appeal, In the Supreme Court of the State of New York, Appellate Division – First Department (publication information unavailable), 104, Storm, et al. v. McGrover, et al., testimony of Minnie Angermiller, p. 104; Google Books (http://www.googlebooks.com : accessed 18 June 2020).

[29] 1880 U.S. census, New York, New York, “Defective, Dependent, and Delinquent Classes,” Bloomingdale Insane Asylum, enumeration district (ED) 529, p. 4, Charles Preiss; image, Ancestry (http://www.ancestry.com : accessed 23 June 2020); citing New York State Education Department, Office of Cultural Education, Albany, New York.

[30] New York, State Department of Health, Death Index, Charles Preiss, 10 April 1899; digital image, Ancestry, (http://www.Ancestry.com : accessed 20 June 2020). 

[31] New York, State Department of Health, Death Index, Caroline Preiss, 16 January 1900; digital image, Ancestry, (http://www.Ancestry.com : accessed 20 June 2020).

[32] Storm, et al. v. McGrover, et al.

[33] New York, Kings Co., Manhattan, marriage certificate, Brockman-Priess, 22 April 1855; “New York, New York City Marriage Records, 1829-1940,” FamilySearch, FHL microfilm not available.

[34] 1870 U.S. census, Essex County, New Jersey, population schedule, Ward 9, p. 299 (stamped), dwelling 814, family 932, William Brockmann; image, Ancestry (http://www.ancestry.com : accessed 23 June 2020); citing National Archives microfilm M593, roll 881. 1880 U.S. census, Essex County, New Jersey, population schedule, enumeration district (ED) 59, p. 8 (penned), house no. 48, dwelling 19, William Brockmann; image, Ancestry (http://www.ancestry.com : accessed 23 June 2020); citing National Archives microfilm T9, roll not noted.

[35] Holbrook’s City and Business Directory of Newark (Newark: A.M. Holbrook, (1887), 211; also subsequent years by the same title: (1890), 219, (1896), 274, (1899) 294; digital images, “U.S. City Directories, 1822-1995,” Ancestry, (http://www.Ancestry.com : accessed 20 June 2020).

[36] Holbrook’s City and Business Directory of Newark (Newark: A.M. Holbrook, (1896), 850; also subsequent years by the same title: (1897), 933, (1898), 1084, (1908), 1041; digital images, “U.S. City Directories, 1822-1995,” Ancestry, (http://www.Ancestry.com : accessed 20 June 2020).

[37] St. Columba’s parish was originally built for Irish immigrants and St. Peter’s for German immigants.

Camp of the 55th New York Infantry near Tenleytown, D.C., ca. 1862; digital image, Library of Congress (https://lccn.loc.gov/2012648010 : accessed 20 June 2020).

Camp of the 55th New York Infantry near Tenleytown, D.C., ca. 1862; digital image, Library of Congress (https://lccn.loc.gov/2012648010 : accessed 20 June 2020).

Stereograph showing Professor Thaddeus S. Lowe observing the battle from his balloon "Intrepid" while soldiers in camp hold the balloon's ropes in Fair Oaks, Virginia; publisher, The War Photograph & Exhibition Co., No. 21 Linden Place, Har…

Stereograph showing Professor Thaddeus S. Lowe observing the battle from his balloon "Intrepid" while soldiers in camp hold the balloon's ropes in Fair Oaks, Virginia; publisher, The War Photograph & Exhibition Co., No. 21 Linden Place, Hartford, Conn., 31 May 1862; digital image, Library of Congress (https://lccn.loc.gov/2011660070 : accessed 20 June 2020). Wonder if Charles is in this picture.

Week 23: “Wedding” #52Ancestors

The picture below is the saddest wedding picture I have ever seen. Or more accurately, not seen.

One of my quarantine projects has been to reorganize and label the family photos I had digitized several years ago.[1] Sadly, when I first started digitizing I hadn’t yet taken any of Maureen Taylor’s online courses so I am now re-doing all my previous work but in a much more organized and logical manner. I am a huge fan of Maureen’s and chat with her most Fridays over zoom where she holds an “office hour.” Maureen is known in the genealogical community as The Photo Detective. In addition to her online courses and books, Maureen also offers photo consultation (by phone or Zoom) to help clients identify the person, place, or era of their mysterious photos. She’s the best![2]  

My husband’s grandmother had this photobook of sorts with photos mounted to three-hole-punched plain white paper. I think the photos likely came from a prior album because some are a bit tattered and look like they were previously glued to black paper. The page I’ve attached had four pictures glued to it. Where the wedding picture is is anybody’s guess.[3]

The date of the marriage in the scrapbook is correct: Edward McCormick and Mary Quinlan were marred at 8 o’clock in the evening on Wednesday, 21 August 1889 by Father John Ward at St. Patrick’s Church in Parsons, Kansas. I know from a newspaper article that her parents held a reception for the couple after the ceremony at their home.[4] The article lists the numerous presents they received and from whom they came. They received a lot of silver such as forks, knives, spoons, berry dish (2), cologne case, syrup pitcher, sugar castor, napkin rings, butter dish, crumb holder, and pickle castor. Quite the hall![5]

St. Patrick’s was established in 1872 by missionaries from the Osage Mission.[6] The picture I’ve attached shows St. Patrick’s second church built in 1883. The couple standing on the right are Edward and Mary. Although the church began with only twenty families, by 1884 the congregation had grown to over 600 members.[7] This tremendous grown doesn’t surprise me: land was readily available, good jobs came with the railroad in the 1870’s, and in looking at the list of folks that attended their wedding, the overwhelming number were of Irish (and likely Catholic) descent: Dowd, McManus, Dunbar, Moran, O’Hare, Harrigan, McGough, McBride, Byrnes, Cloughley, Tierney, etc.[8]

Ed and Mary had been married for forty years when Ed died at age sixty-four in 1929.[9] Mary passed away seven years later at her daughter’s home in Kansas City.[10]


[1] All on Dropbox to share with cousins.

[2] You can find Maureen Taylor, The Photo Detective at https://maureentaylor.com

[3] Hey any of you Baty, McCormick, or Quinlan cousins – if you have it, would you be so kind as to send me a digital copy?

[4] “Ed McCormick and Miss Mary Quinlan were married,” The Parsons (Kansas) Palladium, 4 September 1889, p. 1, col. 4.

[5] Of all those items listed, my husband inherited a cut-glass berry dish the was given to the happy couple by either Mr. and Mrs. James Harrigan or Mr. and Mrs. O’Hare (they received two such dishes).

[6] “History of St. Patrick Catholic Church, Parsons, Kansas,” St. Patrick Catholic Church in Parsons, KS (https://stpatricksparsons.org/home/st-patrick-parish-history : accessed 12 June 2020).

[7] Ibid.    

[8] Wikipedia.org, “Parsons, Kansas,” rev. 16:15, 4 June 2020.

[9] “Obituary,” The Catholic (Wichita) Advance, 12 October 1929, p. 4, col. 2-3.

[10] Missouri State Board of Health, certificate of death no. 44693 (1936), Mary McCormick; digital image, Secretary of State, Missouri Digital Heritage (http://www.sos.mo.gov).

Page from scrapbook with missing wedding picture.

Page from scrapbook with missing wedding picture.

Ed and Mary are the couple on the right (he with mustache). Don’t know who the people are with the penned X on them but guessing they are family as the X is made with same blue ink as was used to ID the people in the album.

Ed and Mary are the couple on the right (he with mustache). Don’t know who the people are with the penned X on them but guessing they are family as the X is made with same blue ink as was used to ID the people in the album.

Black Lives Matter

Say their names and take action:

Michael Brown

Tamir Rice

Walter Scott

Alton Sterling

Philando Castile

Stephon Clark

Jamar Clark

Dreasjon “Sean” Reed

Sandra Bland

Botham Shem Jean

Eric Garner

Laquan McDonald

Calvon “Andre” Reid

Ezell Ford

Michelle Shirley

Redel Jones

Kenny Watkins

Breonna Taylor

George Floyd

Rekia Boyd

Steven Demarco Taylor

Atatiana Jefferson

Ariane McCree

Terrance Franklin

Aiyana Stanley-Jones

Tarika Wilson

Kathryn Johnston

Natasha McKenna

Pamela Turner

Miles Hall

William Green

Samuel David Mallard

E.J. Bradford

Korryn Gaines

Yvette Smith

Michael Dean

Jamee Johnson

Antwon Rose

Natosha “Tony” McDade

Yassin Mohamed

Miriam Carey

Finan H. Berhe

Darius Tarver

Shelley Frey

Darnisha Harris

Kwame “KK” Jones

De’von Bailey

Christopher Whitfield

Kendra James

Tyisha Miller

Anthony Hill

Eric Logan

Jamarion Robinson

Malissa Williams

Shantel Davis

Gregory Hill, Jr.

JaQuavion Slaton

Ryan Twyman

Brandon Webber

Jimmy Atchison

Willie McCoy

Emantic “EJ” Fitzgerald Bradford, Jr.

Jemel Roberson

DeAndre Ballard

Robert Lawrence White

Anthony Lamar Smith

Remarley Graham

Manuel Loggins, Jr.

Wendell Allen

Kendrec McDade

Larry Jackson, Jr.

Jonathan Ferrell

Jordan Baker

Victor White, III

Dontre Hamilton

John Crawford, III

Dante Parker

Kajieme Powell

Akai Gurley

Rumain Brisbon

Jerame Reid

Charly Keunang

Tony Robinson

Freddie Gray

Brendon Glenn

Samuel DuBose

Christian Taylor

Mario Woods

Quintonio LeGrier

Gregory Gunn

Akiel Denkins

Terrence Sterling

Terence Crutcher

Keith Lamont Scott

Alfred Olango

Jordan Edwards

Danny Ray Thomas

DeJuan Guillory

Patrick Harmon

Jonathan Hart

Maurice Granton

Julius Johnson

Sean Monterrosa

Jamel Floyd

 

 

 

 

Campaign Zero: https://www.joincampaignzero.org/#vision

Campaign Zero: https://www.joincampaignzero.org/#vision

https://8cantwait.org

https://8cantwait.org

Week 22: Uncertain #52Ancestors

One of the things I am the most uncertain about in my family research is exactly where in Ireland my five Irish-born second great-grandparents came from. Heck, I don’t even know exactly when they came to America. I know they were all in the U.S. by the late 1840’s – early 1850’s, so they were likely part of the mass migration as a result of the Irish Famine of 1845-1852. I have found only naturalization records for one of the five, but that doesn’t tell me where he came from other than “Ireland.” 

 Ancestry’s autosomal DNA test provides ethnicity estimates not only by country, but also by region within the country. My DNA estimates currently show my family may have come from Connacht, specifically, North Connacht, North Mayo, North East Mayo and North West Sligo. My sister’s DNA test on Ancestry shows those same areas in Connacht. All of this is interesting, but it hadn’t led to any new discoveries. 

 Until last week.

 Scrolling through my aunt’s DNA results last week (I manage her account), I came across a guy with the last name of McDonough who shares 135 cM with her. With that many shared cMs they could be 2nd cousins once removed or 1stcousins three-times removed. Awesome. I immediately dove into his tree and found something that could be a “game-changer.” 

 First, let me back-up a bit.

McDonough is my aunt’s mother’s maiden name (i.e., my grandmother).

For those who may need a DNA refresher, a “cM” is a “centiMorgan,” defined as “a unit of recombinant frequency which is used to measure genetic distance.”[1] Okay, that’s not helpful. Essentially, the genetic testing companies use cMs to “denote the size of matching DNA segments in autosomal DNA tests.”[2] Better? The more cMs you have in common with another person, the more closely related you are. As an example, my aunt shares 3,376 cMs with her daughter and 100% of the time people with that many shared cMs have a parent-child relationship. 

So back to my newly-discovered McDonough cousin. His immigrant ancestor, Mary McDonough, came to the United States with her two children between 1849 and 1855. I haven’t yet found where the family was living in the 1850’s, but I do know that in 1860 they lived in the same small town in New Jersey as my immigrant McDonoughs.[3] In fact, the only McDonoughs in Clinton were Mary’s and Michael’s families. 

 Mary’s children were John and Bridget. Their father Patrick likely died before 1860 and my best guess is that he died before they immigrated.  My new McDonough cousin is a descendent of John’s so that’s where I do a deep-dive.

 John had a thriving florist shop in Newark when he married a Mary Ann Radel in 1873.[4] They had twelve children and lived for the next forty years in Newark. Before 1910, they came back the same town as my McDonoughs.[5] Nothing yet to tell me where in Ireland John or his sister or mother came from. Twelve was a lot of kids to research, but the work payed off when I look at their seventh child Anna and, of all things, her passport application.

 At thirty-four, Anna Meria applied for a passport so that she could go to France to work as a Red Cross Nurse’s Aide during WWI.[6] In that application, she stated that her father was born in County Clair, came to the U.S. in May of 1849 from the port of “Lunbuck,” Ireland.[7]

 I can’t tell you how trilling it is to have even this still uncertain clue as to my Irish origins. 

 So what to do now? I will continue to research this McDonough family because I am finding little tidbits that help reinforce a possible connection. For example, one of John’s sons has the middle name of “Sarsfield” as does my great-grandfather Michael. Coincidence?[8] Maybe not.

 As fun as it is to find these little connections, the definitive connection will come through test DNA. I’ve contacted my new McDonough cousin and am waiting – with baited breath – to hear back from him. What I’ll propose is that he take a Y-DNA test from Family Tree DNA and that my cousin Kevin McDonough do likewise. Another little DNA refresher: The Y chromosome is a male-specific sex chromosome and is passed down virtually unchanged from father to son.[9] If my new cousin and Kevin have a common male ancestor, they should match closely-enough to verify (or disprove) a family connection. Wouldn’t that be something?


[1] International Society of Genetic Genealogy Wiki, “centiMorgan,” (https://isogg.org/wiki/CentiMorgan : accessed 28 May 2020).

[2] Ibid.

[3] 1860 U.S. census, Essex County, New Jersey, population schedule, Clinton, p. 37 (penned), p. 240 (stamped), dwelling 263, family 287, Mary McDonough; image, Ancestry (http://ww.ancestry.com : accessed 1 June 2020); citing National Archives microfilm publication M653, roll not noted. 

[4] New Jersey, Newark, McDonough-Radel, 16 February 1873; database, “New Jersey Marriages, 1678-1985,” FamilySearch(htpp://www.familysearch.org : accessed 1 June 2020).

[5] This may not be such a big deal since Newark and Maplewood aka South Orange aka Hilton aka Clinton was next door. 1910 U.S. census, Essex County, New Jersey, population schedule, South Orange, enumeration district (ED) 219, sheet 4-B, dwelling 78, family 230, Jno F. McDonough; image, Ancestry (http://www.ancestry.com : accessed 1 June 2020); citing National Archives microfilm publication T624, roll 884. 1910 U.S. census, Essex County, New Jersey, population schedule, South Orange, p. 73 (stamped), enumeration district (ED) 219, sheet 29-A, dwelling 571, family 613, Michael McDonough; image, Ancestry (http://www.ancestry.com : accessed 1 June 2020); citing National Archives microfilm publication T624, roll 884.

[6] Anna Meria McDonough Passport Application, 5 September 1918; digital image, “U.S. Passport Applications,” Ancestry (http://www.ancestry.com : accessed 28 May 2020); citing National Archives, Washington, D.C., Roll #592, Certificates: 36250-36499, 21 September 1918-24 September 1918. 

[7] As far as I can tell, there is no such place as “Lunbuck” in Ireland. Given that John left Ireland when he was under ten-years of age and that it had been sixty years since he’d lived there, I am guessing he meant Limerick, which could be a good possibility. 

[8] “U.S., World War II Draft Registration Cards, 1942,” images, Ancestry (http://www.ancestry.com : accessed 28 May 2020), card for Andrew Sarsfield McDonough, serial no. 1831, Local Draft Board 14, East Orange, New Jersey. 1915 New Jersey state census, Essex County, population schedule, South Orange Township, p. 11-A, dwelling 237, family 258, Sarsfield McDonough; image, Ancestry (http://www.ancestry.com : accessed 1 June 2020); citing New Jersey zState Archive, reference no. L-12, film no. 25.

[9] International Society of Genetic Genealogy Wiki, “Y-chromosome DNA” (https://isogg.org/wiki/Portal:Y-chromosome_DNA  : accessed 28 May 2020).

 

Anna Meria McDonough’s passport photo.

Anna Meria McDonough’s passport photo.

From our last trip to Ireland.

From our last trip to Ireland.

Week 21: Tombstone #52Ancestors

My great-grandparents, Michael Sarsfield McDonough and Sarah Elizabeth Getter married on August 31, 1880 at St. Leo Roman Catholic Church in Irvington, New Jersey.[1] The church had been established two years and all sacraments and services were held in a small wooden church until 1926 when a large stone church was built.[2] Michael lived in Maplewood and Elizabeth in Union but neither of those towns had a Catholic church and St. Leo’s was the closest. All of Michael and Elizabeth’s children were baptized at St. Leo’s and my grandparents were married there in 1915. 

Like his father and some of his brothers, Michael was a “market gardener” meaning that he had a small farm that produced fruits, vegetables and flowers and sold directly to consumers.[3]  He and Sarah had six children over the first twelve years after their marriage. I am fortunate to have known my grandmother Mae and her younger sister, Aunt “Wheat” (nickname for Marguerite). 

In about 1905, something when awry between Michael and Elizabeth. According to the 1905 New Jersey state census, Elizabeth was living at the family home on Burnett Avenue in Hilton but Michael (identified as “M. Sarsfield McDonough”) lived nearby on Boyden Avenue. The 1910 U.S. census, shows Michael back home on Burnett Avenue with his wife and children, but then five years later they are again living separately. After 1916, I lose track of him completely. The available city directories list Elizabeth at Burnett Avenue from that 1908 until 1932, the year before her death, but Michael is shown only once in 1916 and not at the family home. Beginning in 1930, Elizabeth identified as a widow however Michael was very much alive. From 1929 until his death in 1943, Michael lived at the Little Sisters of the Poor Home for the Aged in Newark, New Jersey. 

Founded in France, the Congregation of the Little Sisters of the Poor was officially established in 1852.[4] The nuns came to America in 1868 and by the 1950’s the Congregation had fifty-two homes for the aged across the U.S.[5] The Newark home where Michael lived was completed in 1888 and today is an apartment building for low-income seniors.[6] 

I had many opportunities to talk to my aunt about my research into family history. One thing I will never forget is her telling me that she had no idea her grandfather died in 1943 (when she was seventeen). She distinctly remembered when Elizabeth died in 1933 because she was so sad not to have any living grandparents. 

Which brings me to this week’s topic: tombstone. Not only was there no mention of his passing to my dad or aunt, but there is no tombstone for him either. My sister and I went to Holy Sepulchre Cemetery in Orange, NJ where many of our ancestors are buried. There is a beautiful monument on the McDonough plot complete with an Irish cross at the top. There are headstones for everyone buried there, except Michael. The kind woman in the office verified Michael was buried there and I have subsequently located the burial card showing him in the family plot.[7] Even in our massive collection of family photos there is not one of Michael but lots of Elizabeth and even Michael’s father. I can’t imagine what ignominious thing he may have done to be written out of the family history this way? 

 

 

[1] "New Jersey index to records of births, marriages, and deaths, 1848-1900" "Marriages Atlantic-Warren v. 5 1880-1881," McDonough-Getter (1880); digital image FamilySearch (https://www.familysearch.org : accessed 25 July 2018), FHL microfilm 495696, image 103 of 430 .

[2] Rev. John O. Buchmann, “Diamond Jubilee of St. Leo’s Church – Irvington, 1878-1953,” 26 September 1953, 18; digital image Ancestry (http://www.ancestry.com : accessed 21 May 2020). Robert Wister, “Irvington – St. Leo,” Churches of the Archdiocese of Newark, 9 November 2011 (https://blogs.shu.edu/newarkchurches/archives/1155 : accessed 21 May 2020).

[3] Wikipedia.org, “Market garden,” rev. 13:31, 11 May 2020.

[4] “History,” Little Sisters of the Poor (http://littlesistersofthepoor.org/our-life/history/ : accessed 26 May 2020).

[5] “American foundations,” Little Sisters of the Poor (http://littlesistersofthepoor.org/american-foundations/ : accessed 26 May 2020).

[6] “New Community – Roseville,” LowIncomeHousing.us (https://www.lowincomehousing.us/det/07106_new-community-roseville : accessed 26 May 2020).

[7] Holy Sepulchre Cemetery (East Orange, New Jersey), “Cemetery records, 1859-1977,” Michael McDonough burial card, 19 Jan 1943; digital image, FamilySearch (https://www.familysearch.org/search/film/007900333?cat=230108 : viewed 24 Jan. 2018), FHL microfilm 7,900,333. 

 

Sarah Elizabeth Getter McDonough

Sarah Elizabeth Getter McDonough

McDonough Family Home/Farm at 33 Burnett, Maplewood, NJ

McDonough Family Home/Farm at 33 Burnett, Maplewood, NJ

McDonough Monument at Holy Sepulchre Cemetery, East Orange, NJ

McDonough Monument at Holy Sepulchre Cemetery, East Orange, NJ

Week 20: Travel #52Ancestors

My husband and I are currently scheduled to travel to Dublin in August and then on to Scotland. I am certain we all know what will happen to that plan. Crud. On the bright-side, if we all continue to wear our masks, keep-up with social distancing, and give our brilliant scientists a chance to develop an effective vaccine, we will get through this together!

I have been fortunate-enough to do a little traveling in search of ancestors: cemeteries in New Jersey, Kansas, and Missouri and courthouses in Kansas and Missouri. Not big trips and nothing over-seas (yet). For those I use Google Earth which is a miracle. I’ve seen churches in Ireland and Germany where my ancestors were baptized and married. I’ve seen an ancestral home in London and family farm in Ireland. If you haven’t tried it, I highly recommend it but be prepared for a big time-suck!

On June 9, 1931, Nell (Quinlan) Donnelly and her niece, Kathryn (McCormick) Baty left New York for a three to four-month tour of Europe. The Kansas City Star reported that Nell left on May 15th for New York City, a few weeks ahead of the sailing.[1] It is possible that they stayed at the Hotel Biltmore while in the city. I haven’t (yet) found the ship’s manifest for their trip so I don’t (yet) know to what port they arrived. At that time, a trip from New York to Europe would have taken about six days.[2]

On July 2, Kate Baty sent a postcard from Dublin to her sister Bee (Mary Beatrice McCormick) back in Parsons, Kansas.[3] I know that they also traveled to County Cork in Ireland because Kate brought home with her a Certificate of Baptism (“Copied from the Parochial Register”) for John Quinlan from St. Martin’s Parish of Kilworth, County Cork.[4] John was Nell’s father and Kate’s grandfather. I wonder if either Kate or Nell noticed that woman named as John’s mother, Margaret Roche, was incorrect. If you look at the original church register it names Margaret Roche as both his mother and godmother.[5] While there well could have been two women of the same name, other evidence proves that his mother was actually Johanna Roche.[6]

 I don’t know where else Kate and Nell may have traveled in Europe, but they did not stay for three or four months. Instead, they boarded the ocean liner R.M.S Empress of Britain in Cherbourg, France, on July 8, 1931 for the voyage back. I assume Kate and Nell must have done some “touristy” things in France between their time in Dublin and departure. 

 This particular voyage on the Empress of Britain was only its fourth trip across the Atlantic after its maiden voyage on May 27, 1931.[7] The Britain carried about 1,200 passengers with only first class and two tourist-class (i.e. third-class) accommodations. Its Spring-Fall route was Quebec-Southampton-Cherbourg-Quebec. The idea behind this was by leaving from Quebec via the sheltered St. Lawrence seaway, the ship avoided the ice-infested waters off Newfoundland and spent less time on the open waters.[8]

 During her time as a commercial ocean liner, the Britain was one of the fastest and most luxurious ship traveling the Atlantic. Even the third/tourist-class cabins were apparently well-appointed with “full length mirrors, hot and cold running water, … electric heaters, steam heaters, wide corridors … and even a gymnasium.”[9] The first-class accommodations included an “Olympian Pool,” Turkish Bath, playgrounds and toys for children, and “tennis courts, complete with umpire’s high-stooled chair, spectators’ gallery and a private café.”[10] The author of the article I am quoting called it “Babylon afloat.” The cost for first-class accommodations was $292.50 per person each way.[11] I am not surprised Nell and Kate would travel in such luxury. In 1931, Nell’s company, “Nelly Don” was worth over $3.5 million.[12]

Perhaps faithful readers of this blog will remember why Nell and Kate took this trip and came back to the U.S. after only a month? Notice I said that they came back to the U.S. and not “home.” Where did they go? I have no idea. The family story was that Nell and Kate stayed in Europe for the three months and when they came back to Kansas City, Nell brought with her a one-month baby boy she had “adopted” from somewhere in Europe. A long-long-held family secret, only recently did it become common knowledge that the little baby was actually Nell and Senator James A. Reed’s love-child. Nell and Paul Donnelly divorced in November 1932 and she and Reed married the following year.[13]

 Nell and James lived happily until his death in 1944. Nell continued to run her company until 1956 and died in 1991 at the age of 102.[14] One of her many lasting legacies is the James A. Reed Memorial Wildlife Area in Jackson County that she started with a donation of 731 acres to the Missouri Department of Conservation in memory of her husband.[15] Additional tracts of land have been purchased over the years and the area currently consists of 3,084 acres where you can camp, hike, fish, hunt, among other activities.[16]

But what of the Britain? One of her crowning achievements was to take King George VI and Queen Elizabeth back to England in 1939 after their goodwill-tour of North America.[17] However, later that year as World War II approached, the Britain was requisitioned for use as a troop transport. In 1940, while off the west coast of Ireland, she was attacked by German aircraft. Most of the crew made it safely to shore and she was being towed to safety when torpedoes from a German U-boat sunk her. “She was the greatest passenger ship lost by the Allied forces during the entire war.”[18]

Stay safe, my lovelies! 

 


[1] “Mrs. P.F. Donnelly left Friday,” The Kansas City (Missouri) Star, 17 May 1931, p. 26, col. 4.

[2] Jean-Paul Rodrigue, “Liner Transatlantic Crossing Times, 1833-1952 (in days),” The Geography of Transport Systems, 5th ed. (New York: Routledge, 2020); digital image (https://transportgeography.org/?page_id=2135 : accessed 20 May 2020).

[3] Postcard in family collection.

[4] Certificate in family collection.

[5] St. Martin’s, Kilworth Parish, Cloyne Diocese, Cork, Ireland, Registry of Baptisms, 1829-1876, John Quinlan, 8 November 1835; digital image, National Library of Ireland, “Catholic Parish Registers,” microfilm 04996/03, p. 30 (http://registers.nli.ie/registers/vtls000634524#page/30/mode/1up : accessed 20 My 2020). 

[6] For example, the 1851 Irish census shows Johanna, a widow, as head of house with her sixteen-year-old son John. 

[7] Wikipedia.org, “RMS Empress of Britain (1930),” rev. 17:52, 12 May 2020. “Pamphlet listing Atlantic sailings for 1931, No. 99,” Canadian Pacific Steamships, 20 February 1931; digital images, University of British Columbia, Wallace B. Chung and Madeline H. Chung Collection (http://www.open.library.ubc.ca : accessed 20 May 2020). 

[8] Wikipedia, “RMS Empress of Britain (1930),” rev. 17:52, 12 May 2020.

[9] Leslie Roberts, The Empress of Britain, MacLean’s (1 August 1931); digital image, Macleans (https://archive.macleans.ca/article/1931/8/1/the-empress-of-britain : accessed 20 May 2020) 

[10] Ibid.

[11] “Pamphlet,” Canadian Pacific Steamships, 20 February 1931.

[12] “Nell Donnelly Reed is dead at age 102,” The Kansas City (Missouri) Star, 9 September 1991.

[13] “The Romance of Nell Donnelly and Paul F. Donnelly Ends with a Divorce Action in Judge Brown Harris’s Court,” The Kansas City (Missouri) Times, 16 November 1932, p. 5, col. 1-2. Jackson County, Missouri, Recorder of Deeds, James A. Reed-Nell Quinlan Donnelly, License No. A53496, 13 December 1933; digital image, Jackson County, Missouri, Recorder of Deeds Web Access (http://aumentumweb.jacksongov.org/Marriage/SearchEntry.aspx : accessed 20 May 2020). My husband suspects that Paul knew what was going on and acquiesced to the façade. 

[14] “Nell Donnelly Reed is dead at age 102,” The Kansas City (Missouri) Star, 9 September 1991. 

[15] “Reed (James A) Mem Wa,” Missouri Department of Conservation (https://nature.mdc.mo.gov/discover-nature/places/reed-james-mem-wa : accessed 20 May 2020)

[16] Ibid. From Lee's Summit, take Highway 50 east 1 mile, then SE Ranson Road (Route RA) south 0.75 mile to the area entrance.

[17] Henrik Ljungström, “Empress of Britain (II),” The Great Ocean Liners (http://thegreatoceanliners.com/articles/empress-of-britain-ii/ : accessed 20 May 2020).

[18] Ibid.

Nell (Quinlan) Reed, her son David Quinlan Reed, Mary Kathryn Baty and Kate (McCormick) Baty

Nell (Quinlan) Reed, her son David Quinlan Reed, Mary Kathryn Baty and Kate (McCormick) Baty

R.M.S. Empress of Britain, 2 June 1931. Photographer unknown. University of British Columbia, Wallace B. Chung and Madeline H. Chung Collection (http://www.open.library.ubc.ca : accessed 20 May 2020). 

R.M.S. Empress of Britain, 2 June 1931. Photographer unknown. University of British Columbia, Wallace B. Chung and Madeline H. Chung Collection (http://www.open.library.ubc.ca : accessed 20 May 2020). 

First-class lounge on the R.M.S. Empress of Britain, 1931. Photographer unknown. University of British Columbia, Wallace B. Chung and Madeline H. Chung Collection (http://www.open.library.ubc.ca : accessed 20 May 2020). 

First-class lounge on the R.M.S. Empress of Britain, 1931. Photographer unknown. University of British Columbia, Wallace B. Chung and Madeline H. Chung Collection (http://www.open.library.ubc.ca : accessed 20 May 2020). 

Week 19: Service #52Ancestors

My husband has many ancestors who served in the military in the United States starting with a couple who served in colonial Maryland before there even was a United States. He has at least eleven who served in the Revolutionary War, five in the War of 1812, and seven in the Civil War with at least one serving for the Confederacy. My side of the family didn’t come to the U.S. until after the Civil War, with the exception of Charles Edward Spencer, my great-grandfather who came to the U.S. in 1846. I’ve written on Charles before and his claim he served a drummer boy in the Civil War. I am not sure why he made up this story, but I have found his some of his actual service records and they tell a much different story.

Charles came to the U.S. as an infant. I haven’t found the ship’s manifest showing his arrival, but in his naturalization papers he says he arrived at in New York in 1846 (at one-year-old).[1] He filed for naturalization in 1864 in Massachusetts and identified his occupation as “seaman.”  The Massachusetts state census taken in May of 1865 also notes he was in the U.S. Navy.[2]

When I began researching his military history, I got stuck trying to find a Charles Spencer who served as a drummer boy in New Jersey. It wasn’t until completing more general research on Charles that I discovered he lived in Massachusetts before he moved to New Jersey. That lead me to the 1856 census which lead me to his actual military service records. Lesson learned – you may need a broader picture of your ancestor before you focus on the details.

Charles enlisted in the Navy for one year on 7 November 1863 when he was nineteen years old.[3] The enlistment return gives a nice description of what he looked like: he had hazel eyes, dark hair, a dark complexion, and stood 5’ 8 ¾” tall. He had an E.S.” tattooed on his right forearm.[4] His “rating” on the enlistment return said “Ld’s” which I have learned means “landsman,” or one with little or no experience at sea.[5]

Sadly, the Navy did not maintain personnel files for enlisted men until 1885. However, the Archives Specialist at the National Archives found a small file for him that she sent to me as a courtesy.[6] Identified as a “machinist” when he enlisted, Charles first served in the Navy as a nurse. According to this file his “receiving” ship was the USS Ohio to which he reported on 6 January 1864. He served on the USS Pequot and USS Stepping Stones for his term and discharged on 4 October 1864. In researching him further, I find a “card” that shows he also served as a “Surgeon’s Steward” from October 1864 to April 1865 on the USS Monadnock.[7] Cool.

In working on this blog post I discover (to my amazement) that the muster rolls for Civil War vessels have been digitized and are available on the National Archives website.[8] Awesome! While they are not indexed it takes me no time at all to locate the ships Charles served on and to review them page by page. This being my infamously unreliable ancestor, of course I am in for another mystery. 

In reading through the muster rolls (several times) for the Pequot and Stepping Stones, I do not find Charles listed. Both ships did have nurses and surgeon’s stewards, but they were not Charles. How can that be? My best guess is that Charles served as a nurse from January to October 1864 on another vessel before being appointed to the Monadnock. Because these records are not yet indexed I will have to wait to find out where he served during those months (unless I want to spend the rest of the quarantine reading every single muster roll. Lolz). 

The muster rolls of the Monadnock show that Charles was appointed “surgeon’s steward” on October 1, 1864 “for the cruise.”[9] Assigned to brigs and schooners, the “surgeon’s steward” held a rank equivalent to a petty officer.[10] Larger ships would have both a nurse and a surgeon’s steward. The surgeon’s steward performed a variety of duties including assisting the surgeon during an operation, manning the apothecary, and presiding over the sick bay.[11] After the war, the Navy abolished this title in favor of apothecary, a position which would require completion of a course in pharmacy.[12]

The USS Monadnock was a “twin-screwed, wooden-hull, double-turreted, ironclad monitor.”[13] Built by the Boston Navy Yard, it was launched in March 1863 and commissioned 4 October 1864, just when Charles was appointed to serve on her.[14]She participated in the attack on the Cape Fear River in North Carolina in December and January and several more campaigns in early 1865.[15] In April, the Monadnock traveled up the James River to join the last assault on Richmond which caused the Army of Northern Virginia to flee to Appomattox Court House and surrender.[16]

When I think about what Charles must have experienced aboard the Monadnock and the battles he must have witnessed, I wonder why he had to invent a different Civil War story for himself. 

 

 

[1] U.S. Circuit Court, Massachusetts, Primary Declarations of Intention, vol. 14, 29 April 1864 declaration of intention by Charles E. Spencer; digital image, Ancestry (http://www.ancestry.com : accessed 12 May 2020); citing to original data from Nationalization Records, National Archives at Boston, Waltham, Massachusetts. The fact that Charles was in Boston on this date when he was supposed to be aboard ship is interesting and deserves further inquiry.

[2] 1865 Massachusetts state census, Worchester County, population schedule, Blackstone township, Millville Village, dwelling 593, family 787, for Charles E. Spencer in household of Ezekiel Mortimer; digital image, Ancestry (http://www.ancestry.com : accessed 12 May 2020).

[3] U.S. Navy, Weekly Returns of Enlistments at Naval Rendezvous, Enlistments at Boston, 7 November 1863, line 21, Charles E. Spencer; digital image, Fold3 (http://www.fold3.com : accessed 12 May 2020)

[4] This was a good clue that he may have gone by Edward instead of Charles.

[5] Wikipedia.org, “Landsman (rank),” rev. 15:05, 1 February 2020.

[6] Thank you Ms Kim Y McKeithan.

[7] “Index to Rendezvous Reports, Civil War, 1861-1865,” Charles E. Spencer; database with images, Fold3, Rendezvous Reports Index – Civil War” (http://www.fold3.com/title/887/rendezvous-reports-index-civil-war : accessed May 14, 2020).

[8] Record Group 24: Records of the Bureau of Naval Personnel, 1798-2007, Series: “Muster Rolls of Naval Ships, 1/1/1860-6/9/1900,” National Archives Catalog (https://catalog.archives.gov/id/563603 : accessed 12 May 2020).

[9] Department of the Navy, Bureau of Navigation, Series: “Muster Rolls of Naval Ships, Record Group 24: Records of the Bureau of Naval Personnel, 1798-2007, Muster Rolls of the U.S.S. Monadnock 1864-1866; digital image, NARA (https://catalog.archives.gov/id/134432576), National Archives Identifier 134432576, images 10-24.

[10] Michael A. Flannery, “Naval Pharmacy,” Civil War Pharmacy: A History (Carbondale, IL: Southern Illinois University Press, 2017), 170.

[11] HMCS(FMF) Mark T. Hacala, USNR, “History of the Hospital Corps, The U.S. Navy Hospital Corps: A Century of Tradition, Valor, and Sacrifice,” Navy Medicine 89, No. 3 (May-June 1998): 12-26, specifically 12-13; digital copy Google Books (https://www.google.com/books : accessed 14 May 2020). 

[12] Wikipedia.org, “Hospital corpsman,” rev. 22:36, 31 March 2020.

[13] Wikipedia.org, “USS Monadnock (1863),” rev. 03:44, 3 July 2019.

[14] “USS Monadnock,” NavSource Naval History: Photographic History of the U.S. Navy (http://www.navsource.org/archives/01/monadnock1.htm : accessed 12 May 2020). The fact that it was launched in Boston supports the fact that Charles was back there and did not re-enlist at any other port.

[15] Wikipedia, “USS Monadnock (1863),” rev. 03:44, 3 July 2019.

[16] Wikipedia.org, “Third Battle of Petersburg,” rev. 19:06, 2 April 2020.

Charles Edward Spencer, 1914

Charles Edward Spencer, 1914

Lithograph of the Monadnock published in 1864 by Endicott & Company, New York. “USS Monadnock,” NavSource Naval History: Photographic History of the U.S. Navy (http://www.navsource.org/archives/01/monadnock1.htm : accessed 12 May …

Lithograph of the Monadnock published in 1864 by Endicott & Company, New York. “USS Monadnock,” NavSource Naval History: Photographic History of the U.S. Navy (http://www.navsource.org/archives/01/monadnock1.htm : accessed 12 May 2020); courtesy of Commander Charles Moran, 1935.